Wednesday, March 25, 2009

Villanova/Duke Rivalry History - Everything Up to the 1964 NCAA Tournament

To the Villanova Wildcats faithful-

Duke's basketball history is a marvelous tale, lasting over a century, filled with championships, lore, and characters that would fill volumes. In these posts, I'm trying to intersect Villanova's own unique history within it. The schools have met rarely - just ten times - but there's nothing better than seeing two great, storied programs battling in the NCAA tournament in March. So here's the beginning of the story, in Durham, North Carolina, at the dawn of the twentieth century...

Duke basketball predates Villanova basketball by 15 years. In fact, it even predates being named Duke. It was originally Trinity College, affiliated with the Methodist Church. The first game for Trinity was - fittingly enough - against Wake Forest, on March 2, 1906. It was not an auspicious beginning, however. Wake Forest won easily, 24-10.

The arrival of the sport on campus was due to the fact that a 1900 Trinity graduate, Wilbur Wade "Cap" Card, had done postgraduate work at Harvard, and New England was the birthplace of the sport. Card returned to Durham and brought the new sport with him in 1906.

In a remarkably prescient article, The Chronicle student newspaper made the following report, six weeks before the debut against Wake Forest:
"It is well-nigh a certainty that Trinity is to have another game added to her list of athletic sports in the near future. The game is question is basket ball [with a space between the words], one of the most fascinating and most intensely interesting indoor sports known today.

Anyone witnessing it will never forget it. The play is extremely fast and vigorous, yet open enough for an onlooker to follow the movement of the ball and the players."
The Duke media guide, the source for this quote and many of the facts in this article, accurately notes, "The assessment still holds true 103 years later."

Despite its defeat, the Trinity team was willing to give Wake Forest another try, and so the second game ever was a reciprocal trip to Winston-Salem. But two weeks after winning in Durham, Wake Forest won the second game, 15-5, to sweep the season series, so to speak. (It wasn't all bad the first year, though, as the team won two out of three games with "Trinity Park", to finish with a 3-2 record.)

So by the time Villanova got basketball rolling in 1920-21, Trinity/Duke was a veteran program, having played the sport for 15 years. But less than a decade after inaugurating the sport on the Main Line, Villanova faced Duke for the first time.

The Wildcats had decided to make a Southern road trip, to open their season. Their first four games were @ "Montclair A.C.", @ Wake Forest, @ North Carolina State, and @ Duke. After losing to Montclair AC, they defeated Wake Forest, lost to NC State, and wound up in Durham, NC, and faced Duke on December 19, 1930. It was the season opener for Duke. Cameron Indoor Stadium did not even exist yet; it wouldn't open until 1940. Fittingly enough, the Blue Devils - as they were already known by then - were being coached by Cameron himself. Eddie Cameron had become head coach in 1926, four years earlier.

The Blue Devils had become a powerhouse in the Southern Conference (the ancestor of the modern ACC and SEC), having posted a 18-2 record the previous year. The game took place in Card Gym, the predecessor of Cameron Indoor Stadium, and named after the Trinity/Duke alumnus who had brought the new sport from New England a quarter-century earlier. And Villanova defeated Duke, 22-21, in a thriller.

In spite of what was undoubtedly an exciting contest, the schools would not meet again for another quarter-century - and ironically, it would be Duke's first-ever appearance in the NCAA tournament. The first-round battle of the much-smaller tournament took place in Madison Square Garden.

In 1955, Villanova defeated Duke in the Blue Devils' first-ever NCAA tournament game - this year marks their 33rd appearance (and the 30th for Villanova). It was the NCAA tournament first round, on March 8 of that year, and the Wildcats escaped with a 74-73 victory in what also must have been an extraordinarily exciting game... It was just as much of a thriller as the 22-21 game in Durham, a quarter-century earlier, although with far higher offensive output, obviously. There was a great deal of scoring, particularly for a game taking place prior to the introduction of the shot clock and three-point shot.

Perhaps because the NCAA battle was such great entertainment, the schools decided to meet during the ensuing regular season, 1955-56. The Blue Devils made their first visit to the Palestra to face Villanova in particular (as opposed to Penn, and other Big Five schools), on December 17, 1955.

(Note to Duke fans who might not be familiar with it - Villanova played many home games, including most of its high-profile opponents, at the historic Palestra on the campus of the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia, prior to the construction of the on-campus Pavilion in 1986.)

Duke won the first non-cliffhanger game in the series, defeating the host Wildcats 86-76 in another high-octane game.

The series skipped the 1956-57 season, but resumed for the next two seasons with a home-and-home series. On December 14, 1957, Villanova traveled down to Durham for the first time since the initial meeting back in 1930. This time, the host Blue Devils won, 60-53.

When Duke returned to the Palestra on December 20, 1958, the Wildcats won 74-67. Unfortunately, the intersectional regular-season series died for some reason, and would not be revived until the 1990s.

The next meeting came in the 1964 NCAA tournament, the first time the teams had met in over five years. On March 13, 1964, Jack Kraft's Villanova team defeated Providence (the Big East did not exist yet) in the first round, but fell to the Blue Devils, 87-73, in the second round. (The Wildcats did defeat Princeton, in the consolation round that existed at the time.)
The Wildcat players included Bill Melchionni, Wali Jones, George Leftwich, Richie Moore, Bernie Schaffer, and Jim Washington.

Check back for more posts, both on the history of Villanova/Duke, and a comprehensive preview of Thursday's Sweet 16 contest, at around 10 PM in Boston...

You can also take a look at the Various Viewpoints on the right sidebar, for their takes...

Go Wildcats!

There are two ways you can contact Villanova Viewpoint. One is by commenting on this blog. Comments are encouraged. Also, you can e-mail (Important note: This is a different e-mail address than before. Please use this new one.)


Anonymous said...

The 1964 game was brutal. In those days, we didn't have the games on TV, but it was carried on local radio. Philadelphia radio? WWVU? Can't recall, but I think it was commercial station because I listened to it off campus.

Hard to believe that great VU team was beaten, but some guy named Mullins just hammered us. He must have gone off for 30 points. Every time we climbed back into the game, you'd hear the announcer report that Mullins had another basket.

Heart breaking end to great season.


Villanova Viewpoint Publisher said...

Hello, Seamus-

You have quite a memory. From digging through the very comprehensive Duke media guide-

The Duke Blue Devil was, in fact, Jeff Mullins, who played from 1962-64 (no freshman eligibility, then, of course). He scored 43 points in that game, in which Duke scored 87 points, in Raleigh, NC.

He was the leading scorer on that team, averaging 24.2 pts/game (nobody else had more than 13.8).

Mullins eventually scored 1,884 points, and he's still #16 on Duke's all-time scoring list (which includes a lot of prolific scorers, obviously).

Duke beat UConn in the next round, 101-54, in which he scored 30 points, also in Raleigh. The Blue Devils beat Michigan in the Final Four and then lost to UCLA in the championship game, in which Mullins scored 22 points, in Kansas City.

Anonymous said...

Hah! I was going to say Mullins must have gone off for 40 -- but I thought, "Naw, that's just exaggerating!" Well, he just killed us that night. Hard to forget.

Must say I liked tonight's game. Another blowout of a legendary program is always nice. We are playing extremely well. Our defense is truly something; may be the best defensive game I've seen from our guys. Totally frustrated UCLA and Duke.

With about 7 minutes to go, CBS on West Coast switched to Missouri - Memphis game, so I missed a lot.

Got back for the last minute in time to see Tchuisi make his four points. He looks like nice athlete -- hope he gets to play in Europe. Wish I could have seen Coach K's twisted, bad-tempered little face as the 'Cats schooled them.

Blue Devils didn't look like they deserved #2 seed tonight. Obama was apparently right and wrong about Duke. Right that they wouldn't make the Final Four and wrong that they would get past the Wildcats!


Villanova Viewpoint Publisher said...

Hello, Seamus-

Well, it took 45 years, but you finally got to see the Wildcats top Duke in the NCAA tournament...

(I can understand your skepticism that it had really been a 40-point outburst - back then, that was a lot of points for one player...)

It's a shame that you didn't see the end on the West Coast, as the lead widened... but the best moments of the second half were unquestionably seeing the practice players enter the game (with over one minute remaining) and Tchuisi scoring two baskets...

Still can't believe this happened...

Anonymous said...

That game actually was on TV, I watched the entire game. As I was only 8, I don't remember what channel or announcer, but I'm guessing it would seem to have had to have been Channel 6 with Les Keiter, as it was before UHF and I'm sure there was no national coverage.
As for the game, it was only the second college basketball game I had ever seen. I remember the refs let Hack Tyson and Jay Buckley get away with virtual murder in the paint. As was mentioned, Jeff Mullins couldn't miss, and most of his shots were of NBA distance 3 point distance. He even made a halfcourt shot at the first half buzzer.
Villanova was behind early and was in serious foul trouble but made a run in the second half. As I recall Eric Ericson made a number of shots and they got to within 4 or 6 points, but ran out of gas.
I still have great memories of that game though. There is a box score of the game on Charlie Board's ACC website.

Mike Keville said...

1964 VU vs DUKE
No one seems to recall that both Wally Jones and Jim Washington were fouled out of that game in Raleigh for the first time all year for either player. Is it any wonder that VU was refereed to death in the deep South in 1964?

It was on tv and I despise Duke to this very day.