Friday, January 15, 2010

#4 Wildcats Host #11 Georgetown Hoyas on Sunday - A Concise Rivalry History

To the Wildcat faithful-

I thought that it might be a good time, with the #4 Wildcats hosting the #11 Hoyas on Sunday at the Wachovia Center, to take a look at the long history of the rivalry between Villanova and Georgetown, and how it has intersected over the years...

The Villanova/Georgetown Rivalry History

Villanova's legendary rivalry with Georgetown is truly remarkable. The greatest game in Villanova history took place on April 1, 1985, when the Wildcats defeated the heavily-favored Hoyas, to capture the NCAA championship. For more on the traditions and rivalry, please keep reading... At the end of this article, I will tell the story of the 1985 game, the most thrilling game I have ever seen, in any sport.

But before I do so, I will describe the rise of the Hoya empire. Villanova's upset is fully appreciated, when one considers what the Wildcats had to face.
In marked contrast to Villanova, Georgetown had little basketball tradition, prior to the arrival of John Thompson in 1972.

(N.B.  I'd like to thank Georgetown commenter HoyasWinHoyasWin for his helpful correction, which he shares very candidly in his comment below.  He accurately noted that the post did not include Georgetown's most recent banner season, 2006-07, which saw the Hoyas return to the Final Four for the first time since - well - Villanova/Georgetown in 1985.  I regret the oversight.  This Georgetown history, much of which had been composed in early 2007, had not been updated to include that achivement.  I regret the oversight and error.

Accordingly, you'll see italicized and strikethrough text; italicized reflect his corrections, strikethrough the erroneous text.) 

First - The perennial question: "What Is A Hoya?"
I will quote the Georgetown media guide: "In the days when all Georgetown students were required to study Greek and Latin, the University's teams were nicknamed "the Stonewalls". A student, using Greek and Latin terms, started the cheer, "Hoya Saxa", which translates as "What rocks!" The name proved popular, and the term Hoyas was eventually adopted for all Georgetown teams.

Georgetown's colors are blue and gray, and the direct inspiration for them was the Civil War. During the war, Georgetown's location on the Potomac river placed it at the border between Union and Confederacy. Maryland and the District of Columbia were part of the Union. But Virginia, across the river, was the most populous and important state of the Confederacy. In addition to its location, many Georgetown alumni, the "sons of Georgetown", had fought for each side. (It was an all-male school at the time.) 

In light of those facts, Georgetown decided to adopt blue and gray as its colors: the Union soldiers had worn blue uniforms while many Confederate armies had worn gray. Like the nation, the Georgetown community itself had been divided during the conflict. The symbolism was intended as a healing gesture, to reunite after the war.

Thompson, a member of the College Basketball Hall of Fame, is a genuine legend. Due to his success and his powerful personality, he remains one of the best known college basketball coaches in America. However, Thompson's accomplishments are even more remarkable, in light of the Georgetown program which he inherited. Thompson literally constructed the Hoyas' program, brick by brick, for over a quarter of a century.

Georgetown's program is among the oldest in the nation, as it observed its centennial anniversary last season. The Hoyas' first season (just four games) was 1906-1907: the Hoyas played nearby George Washington three times, and one against Virginia. The program did enjoy some success during the 1920s, posting some strong records. However, the success predated both the NCAA tournament and the NIT. Villanova traveled to Georgetown in the Wildcats' second season of play, 1921-22. But the Wildcats fell, 39-34. Surprisingly, due to the close proximity of the schools, the teams would not play again for 23 years!

In 1943, Georgetown qualified for postseason play, for the first time in school history. Led by Elmer Ripley, the Hoyas went 22-5 and qualified for the NCAA tournament, held at New York's Madison Square Garden that year. The talented Mr. Ripley must have been a great coach: at that time, the NCAA tourney invited only eight teams! Georgetown defeated New York University and DePaul to reach the national championship game. But Wyoming whipped the Hoyas, 46-34, to win the national championship. In the consolation game, Georgetown topped Toledo and thus finished in third place. 

>Note: An anonymous commenter below, has provided some clarification on the history, and shared some interesting facts about the 1943 Hoyas.  I regret the error, and would like to thank him for clarifying the history....
The Hoyas finished as runners-up in '43 (not third place). The win over NIT runner-up Toledo following the NCAA tournament was in the Sportswriter's Playoff, a charity event between the finalists of each tournament.

> The Hoyas have reached the NCAA Elite Eight 9 times (1943, 1980, 1982, 1984, 1985, 1987, 1989, 1996 & 2007); the '43 Elite Eight only represents an invitation to the then-8-man tournament, but the Hoyas did go all the way to the final game that year, as noted above.
Unfortunately for Georgetown, its next two seasons were canceled due to World War II. I speculate that due to the school's DC location, its building was commandeered for military use. For example, in Philadelphia, Penn's Palestra was used for Navy administrative offices. However, no Big Five team's schedule was canceled due to the war.

After the war ended in 1945, Villanova and Georgetown began a spirited rivalry. Three months after the Japanese surrender, Villanova hosted the Hoyas for the first time. The Wildcats won, 40-37. For the next four years, they played each other twice a season, foreshadowing the twice-a-year rivalry in the BIG EAST. Georgetown swept Villanova in 1947, and the teams split the 1948 series. But Villanova swept the Hoyas, during the next two seasons.

For some reason, the series ended after the 1950 season. Three decades would ensue, before the creation of the BIG EAST in 1980. Surprisingly, the teams played each other only three times, over those 30 years.

In 1953, Georgetown made its first NIT appearance: it was still the era when the NIT was probably more prestigious than the NCAAs. The Hoyas went 13-7, and lost to Louisville in the first round. They wouldn't return to post-season play until 1970, earning another NIT bid and losing in the first round to Louisiana State.

Thompson arrived in DC, taking over for the 1972-73 season. He inherited a moribund Georgetown program, which had gone 3-23 the previous season. Georgetown's "tradition" was a grand total of three post-season appearances: two NIT bids and a NCAA third-place second-place finish.

Naturally, nobody expected that Georgetown would become even a respectable program, let alone a powerhouse. The idea that the Hoyas would become one of the most prominent and successful teams in the nation was utterly absurd. But Thompson was the architect and visionary that made it possible. In 1975, Thompson's third season, the Hoyas made their first trip to the NCAA tournament in 32 years. While Georgetown lost in the first round, it began one of the most remarkable eras in college basketball.

The Hoyas won the 1984 national championship, and reached the Final Four in 1982 and 1985 and 2007. Georgetown also has made four five trips to the Elite Eight, the most recent two most recent being in 1996, led by Allen Iverson -  and the Hoyas' most recent trip to the Final Four was in 2007.  Georgetown was one of the eight original members of the BIG EAST, in 1979-1980. Villanova joined as the ninth team, one year later.

That brings us to the miraculous game, on April 1, 1985, when Villanova beat Georgetown and captured the NCAA championship!

That season was the first year that the NCAA tournament consisted of 64 teams, up from 48. At 19-10, it was unclear as to whether Villanova would even receive a bid: the Wildcats received a #8 seed. There is a consensus among national observers, that Villanova made the most unbelievable, miraculous run of any team in the NCAA tournament, before or since. The Wildcats defeated #9 seed Dayton on Dayton's home floor (teams are no longer permitted to play on their home floor.) Villanova then upset the #1 seed, Michigan, to head for the Sweet 16. 

The Wildcats then flew to Birmingham, Alabama, and knocked off ACC powers Maryland and North Carolina. It was Villanova's first Final Four appearance since 1971, when the Wildcats lost to UCLA in the final. (Villanova's games were ultimately forfeited due to Howard Porter signing with an agent, prior to the tournament, rendering him ineligible.)

Two other BIG EAST teams, Georgetown and St. John's, joined 'Nova in Lexington, Kentucky. Villanova surprised Memphis State in the national semifinal, while Georgetown stopped St. John's. Georgetown was considered a virtual lock for the national title. The Hoyas were the defending national champions, and entered the game at 35-2. (Georgetown's only two losses had been to St. John's and Syracuse, by a total of three points.)

Moreover, Georgetown had been routinely thrashing 'Nova, since the Wildcats had entered the BIG EAST in 1981. The Hoyas had won nine of the eleven games in that span, many by convincing margins. In 1985, there was only a slight glimmer of hope. Villanova had battled the Hoyas in two close losses that season: a 57-50 loss at Georgetown and a heartbreaking, 52-50 overtime loss at the Spectrum. Nonetheless, nobody other than Rollie and the Wildcats thought that they had a chance to come out on top.

College basketball observers everywhere agree that Villanova played "The Perfect Game," defeating the Hoyas, 66-64, to bring home the national championship to the Main Line! Villanova shot 22-27 from the floor, an unthinkable 78.6%. The Wildcats took only ten shots in the second half, making nine of them.

Surprisingly, prior to the arrival of Jay Wright, on the subject of the commemoration of the 1985 championship, there was only very minimal acknowledgment of the championship in the Pavilion. Subsequently, under the Wright regime, a fitting and proper mural of the 1985 national championship team has been added to the ground floor of the Pavilion lobby. Nonetheless, there should be a mini-museum to tell the story. The mural was a good start, but more still needs to be done for proper commemoration.

The best illustration of Georgetown's stature: Villanova played The Perfect Game - and only won by two!More recently, there has been another Villanova victory over Georgetown to savor. On January 30, 1999, Villanova pulled off a 93-90, double-overtime, miraculous win over Georgetown at the then-First Union Center. (I attended the game, and it was the most exciting finish that I've ever seen live.)

In the second OT, we trailed 90-87, with five seconds to go. Georgetown was at the foul line. After the Hoya missed two shots, Howard Brown hit a three-pointer from the corner to tie the game with one second remaining. Georgetown carelessly inbounded the ball, it was stolen by Brooks Sales, and Jermaine Medley hit a three-pointer at the buzzer to win it...

Another worthwhile note: The Wildcats were the first opponent to play Georgetown at the new MCI (now Verizon) Center, in December 1997 - and won.

Various Viewpoints

Also, go get the full roundup on the upcoming game with Georgetown, from the other Villanova sites:

I Bleed Blue and White

greyCat at
Villanova By the Numbers

Nova News

Go Wildcats!

There are two ways you can contact Villanova Viewpoint. One is by commenting on this blog. Comments are encouraged, welcomed, and will always be answered.

Also, you can e-mail (Important note: This is a different e-mail address than before. Please use this new one.)


HoyasWinHoyasWin said...

Most recent elite eight in '96 ? UNC would disagree, it's Calipari that has his final fours vacated. Ah well, understandably the quality of a Villanova education is difficult to conceal. Maybe grad school in DC ?

Villanova Viewpoint Publisher said...

Hello, HoyasWinHoyasWin-

Thanks for visiting, and for the correction. I do my best to make my posts as accurate as possible, and I regret the error.

I appreciate your time. I often learn a great deal from the reactions of readers, especially of Villanova opponents.

As you can see, if you read the revised version of the post, I've incorporated your correction into the post and given you full credit for doing so.

Thanks - good luck Sunday...

Anonymous said...

A few corrections:

> The Hoyas finished as runners-up in '43 (not third place). The win over NIT runner-up Toledo following the NCAA tournament was in the Sportswriter's Playoff, a charity event between the finalists of each tournament.

> The Hoyas have reached the NCAA Elite Eight 9 times (1943, 1980, 1982, 1984, 1985, 1987, 1989, 1996 & 2007); the '43 Elite Eight only represents an invitation to the then-8-man tournament, but the Hoyas did go all the way to the final game that year, as noted above.

I don't object to the modest Wildcat-favored tone -- you've kept it reasonable and civil, and I don't think there was a team in the NCAA's at the time to whom I'd rather have seen the Hoyas lose in '85. You are right to note the near-perfection necessary for Rollie's "family" to beat the team of the 80s in their most dominant year.

Villanova Viewpoint Publisher said...


Thanks for providing the detailed clarification. I've now inserted your information into the post and struck through the errors.

In addition to the information, I appreciate your characterization of the history post as "reasonable and civil". I do my best to keep all dialogues that way.

It was a great game on Sunday. I'm sure it'll be another battle at the Verizon Center in the second game...