Friday, February 16, 2007

Preview of #14 Georgetown @ Villanova, Saturday, Feb. 17, 2007, noon @ Wachovia Center


By Craig Dimitri
E-mail:
novaviewpoint@yahoo.com

The Wildcats will face the #14 Georgetown Hoyas on Saturday, February 17, 2007, at high noon at the Wachovia Center in South Philadelphia. In January, they stopped a seven-game Hoya winning streak; now, they must ratchet it up a bit, in order to break an eight-game Georgetown winning streak, the longest such streak for Georgetown in Big East play in nearly 20 years (1989 was the last time it happened...) A comprehensive preview…

Georgetown is celebrating its basketball centennial this season, as it has an extremely ancient program. Villanova's did not start until 1920-21, almost a generation later.

The Viewpoint on the #14 Georgetown Hoyas

Coach: John Thompson III, who spent four years at the helm of Princeton (where he also played, graduating in 1988) and now in its third season at Georgetown, 61-28 record. Guided the Hoyas to a 23-10 record in 2005-06 and to the Sweet 16.

2006-07 season analysis:
9-2 Big East, 19-5 overall, RPI rank #26

Nonconference Schedule


Georgetown’s record is impressive. At the same time, it should be noted that they faced a reasonably arduous nonconference schedule, and by Georgetown historical standards, extremely arduous. This is yet another area where JT III does not in fact resemble his father. The elder JT was notorious for loading his December schedule with the highest transfat content in America, playing some of the weakest opponents in the old, decrepit Capital Centre in distant Landover, Maryland.

In contrast, Georgetown’s strength of schedule (SOS) as calculated by Jerry Palm of CollegeRPI.com, as of Sunday, February 11, 2007, is at a respectable #38. (Villanova has one of the toughest, ranked at #6). The Hoyas even invaded Cameron Indoor Stadium at Duke in December, which is the sort of place that his father would avoid like the plague in December. Duke’s weakness this year means that the Hoyas’ loss there does not give them the RPI bump it ordinarily would have, but GU deserves credit for scheduling the home-and-home. Other power-conference games: the Hoyas also traveled to Michigan and Vanderbilt, while losing at home to Oregon.

Cupcakes: Georgetown racked up some easy wins over Hartford, @ Fairfield, Ball State, James Madison, Oral Roberts, newly-Division I Winston-Salem State (whom I believe shares the Lawrence Joel Coliseum in that North Carolina town with Wake Forest), Towson, and Navy. They also had a home loss to Old Dominion, but the Monarchs are having a solid season, ranked #58 by the RPI.


(To the current students reading this – ODU is one of the chief villains in Villanova basketball history. As a #14 seed, Petey Sessoms led the Monarchs to a shocking upset of the Kerry Kittles/Jason Lawson/Alvin Williams/Jonathan Haynes Wildcats, a #3 seed, in triple overtime on St. Patrick’s Day in 1995. That team roared into the NCAA tournament after winning the Big East tournament title, the only Villanova team to do so, before or since.)

The only common opponent with VU, outside of the Big East, was Navy. Both Big East schools hosted the Midshipmen, but Georgetown had a much easier time sinking Navy, sending the Midshipmen to the bottom of the Potomac by an easy 65-44 margin. In contrast, the Wildcats had a much more difficult time sinking Navy, to the bottom of the Schuylkill, winning just 70-61, on November 25, 2006, at the Pavilion.

Big East Schedule


The Hoyas embark upon the Villanova trip on a torrid tear, having won eight consecutive games. Their most recent loss was in mid-January, losing @ then-#7 Pitt, 74-69 on Jan. 13, five days after falling by four points, to the Wildcats at the Verizon Center (where Villanova remains inexplicably undefeated, since the building opened in 1998!)

The Hoyas actually stumbled a bit out of the gate, beating Notre Dame and then losing at home to ‘Nova and @ Pitt. Villanova’s victory snapped a seven-game winning streak for Georgetown. However, in the subsequent eight-game winning streak, they have been very impressive, not just in the caliber of opponent but in the margins of victory. After the loss to Pitt, seven of the eight victories have been by double-digits. And in an ominous sign for Villanova, Georgetown’s two most recent conquests have been blowout victories over quality opponents in Marquette and West Virginia.

First, they made the New Jersey road trip, to both Rutgers and Seton Hall in three days, and beat both of them by double-digits (RU is dangerous in the RAC, even when they are bad, like this year). They returned to DC, pounded DePaul and Cincinnati, and then went back on the road – where first they crushed St. John’s, 72-48. And in what was the most incredible victory of all, properly garnering national attention – the Hoyas wrecked Louisville’s dedication of Denny Crum Court at Freedom Hall, winning 73-65 on Feb. 7, 2007. The Hoyas then returned home and mauled # Marquette by 18 points, 76-58 on February 10, 2007. On Monday, February 12, they crushed West Virginia, 71-53.
Georgetown Starters/Rotation

The Georgetown starting five is set in concrete: Hibbert, Green, and Wallace have started all 24 games, with Sapp starting all but one, and Summers all but three. They have some additional depth, though, in light of such a rigid starting lineup. It’s in theory a eight-man rotation, but the starters have the bulk of the minutes, with the sixth, seventh, and eighth players all averaging 12.3 min/game or less. Of the starters, all but Roy Hibbert can shoot from the perimeter, with varying degrees of success. (Ironically, although the pure Princeton system calls for even big men to take a three-pointer every once in a while, Hibbert has yet to take an attempt from long-range.)


The Player to Stop


#55 Roy Hibbert - 7-2 - Jr - Center- 13.4 points/6.4 rebounds/2.4 blocks/26.1 min/per game (Adelphia, MD)

Hibbert is the linchpin of Georgetown’s team, and stopping him is critical to the Wildcats’ hope of success. His one discernible weakness is his tendency to slide into foul trouble. He averages only 26.1 min/game, a low total for a star player, and the chief reason for that is that he also averages 2.4 personal fouls/game, tied for tops on the team.

Other Starters

#2 Jonathan Wallace - 6-1 - Junior - Guard - 11.3 points/2.8 rebounds/3.1 assists/2.5 turnovers/30.9 min/per game (Harvest, AL)

Wallace is vulnerable to Villanova’s intense defensive schemes, as he committed half a dozen turnovers in the first game, and through the whole season, he has only a few more assists than turnovers. Like Hibbert, he is also prone to foul trouble, averaging 2.4 fouls per contest.

Despite those limitations, Wallace is of central importance to the Georgetown offense. is a stellar marksman from three-point range, shooting an incredible 48.4% from that range and an impressive 51% from the floor. This makes him particularly valuable, as the Princeton motion offense places a premium on the three-point shot – one of its central tenets is that three-point shots should be taken without defenders in the way, something the weave strives to do on a regular basis. In addition, even for a guard, he is a great foul shooter, converting 88.7% of his shots from the line. Great shooter, mediocre ball-handler.

#21 Jesse Sapp - 6-3 - Sophomore - Guard - 8.8 points/3.6 rebounds/3.2 assists/1.8 turnovers/31.9 min/per game (New York, NY)

Sapp takes fewer three-point attempts than Wallace, but is far less talented at them, shooting only 32.9% from that range. Villanova will need to permit open looks on the perimeter, and one of Villanova’s goals will be to assure that Sapp, rather than Wallace, Summers or Green, receives those opportunities. OK foul shooter for a guard (67.4%). With the mid-season departure of Marc Egerson (see below), Sapp and Wallace are the only reliable ball-handlers the Hoyas have and if one or both fall into foul trouble, Georgetown will have enormous problems

# 3 Dajuan Summers - 6-8 - Freshman - Forward - 9.0 points/3.2 rebounds/24.1 min/per game (Baltimore, MD)

Summers was the star for the Hoyas in the first game, as we discuss below in “What to Expect”. Of the five starters, he is the one who missed three starts and also plays the fewest minutes. Good foul shooter, at 75%, and another dangerous perimeter threat at 38.9% from beyond the arc.

#32 Jeff Green - 6-9 - Junior - Forward - 13.2 points/5.9 rebounds/3.7 assists/2.8 turnovers/32.5 min/per game (Hyattsville, MD)

For a 6-9 forward, Green handles the ball a lot, as his high total of assists, as well as turnovers, indicate. The team leader in minutes played, he is a great three-point threat at 41.5%, and well as 77.5% from the line.

Off the Bench

A Player No Longer With the Program

#34 Marc Egerson 6-6 - Sophomore - Guard/Forward - 7.5 points/4.0 rebounds/24.1 min/per game (Wilmington, DE)

Egerson had been the clear sixth man, playing the most minutes by far of any bench player, and also starting three games. However, he had only participated in 13 games this season - a good foul shooter and a weak perimeter shooter. His final game was the December 30, 2006 trip to Michigan. Obviously, he was not all that crucial, as he didn't play a single BE game and the Hoyas are 9-2 without him.
On January 5, 2007, Egerson announced that he was leaving the Georgetown program, due to personal rebounds. The Washington Times speculated at the time that Egerson might have been unhappy that JT III had appareently recruited "over" him, so to speak, with the next recruiting class. Regardless of the reason for Egerson's departure, however, his loss means a considerable lack of depth, particularly due to his role as one of the trio of ball-handlers,.as none of the other bench players play significantly. The three bench players are likely non-factors.

#5 Jeremiah Rivers 6-4 - Freshman - Guard - 1.3 points/1.5 rebounds/12.3 min/per game (Winter Park, FL)

#1 Vernon Macklin 6-9 - Freshman - Forward - 3.4 points/1.5 rebounds/11.5 min/per game (Portsmouth, VA)

# 33 Patrick Ewing, Jr. 6-8 - Junior - Forward - 3.4 points/1.6 rebounds/10.9 min/per game (Marietta, GA, via Indiana University)

The younger Patrick Ewing also wears his father’s #33. He’s not as big, fortunately for the Big East, being only 6-8 and thus not big enough to be the dominant post player his father was. Ironically, he did not initially attend Georgetown. Instead, he opted for Indiana, where he played for two years, and then transferred, possibly because of the ascension of JT III as head coach. Ewing, Jr., sat out 2005-06 as a transfer, and is newly eligible. He’s the ninth man, though, in a nine man rotation.

Overall Analysis of the Hoyas

JT III has opted to install the pure version of the Princeton offense, which he learned as both a player and while the head coach at the elite school, which Pete Carril had devised and perfected, for so many years. It is a gorgeous illustration of the method of play of days gone by, with its emphasis on weaving, cutting, bounce passes, and the like. Carril actually tried very hard to keep its secrets within the Princeton family, correctly recognizing that if the offense became commonplace, it would be easier for opponents to stop. Accordingly, only Princeton family members (of which JT III was one, as a former player and eventual head coach) were let in on its true nuances, guarded as carefully as the inner workings of Freemasonry. Other schools have had some success with it, most notably NC State, although the Wolfpack’s Herb Sendek had to puzzle it out on his own, not being a member of the Princeton inner circle.

As a result, the transformation of Georgetown’s program is one of the most radical undertaken, by any significant program in the entire history of the sport. The formula of his father was to play incredibly ugly basketball, with an emphasis on tenacious and aggressive defense. As a result, the typical Georgetown game in that era was slow, marred with fouls, hideous shot selection, and scores in the 40s and 50s. In fairness, Thompson had a glittering run of success with this strategy, as he did win a national championship, go to three NCAA title games, and produce a stellar list of NBA players such as Sleepy Floyd, Patrick Ewing, Alonzo Mourning, Dikembe Mutombo, and the long-time 76er star Allen Iverson, to name just a few. (See the Villanova/Georgetown Rivalry History for more on that era.)

After Thompson resigned in the midst of the 1998-99 season due to a highly messy and public divorce, one of his inner-circle disciples, Craig Esherick, took over the program. Esherick had played under Thompson and also served as an assistant for many years, and by and large, he continued the formula established by his mentor. However, Esherick – for a variety of reasons too numerous to deal with year – did not enjoy anything beyond modest success in the five-plus seasons at the helm. Out of six postseasons, the only feathers in the Hoyas’ collective cap were a NIT championship and one NCAA tournament bid. This decline took place, ironically, at the same time that Georgetown had finally developed a significant home-court advantage. Beginning with the 1998 season, the Hoyas moved from the dilapidated Capital Centre – located in distant Landover, MD – to the plush new MCI Center (now Verizon), located in downtown DC. Fans, especially students, now had a state-of-the-art facility as well as a much shorter trip.

Esherick, after a long siege shared by his AD, Joe Lang (who was encumbered by the albatross of foolishly stating – at least, publicly – that it was unreasonable to expect that Georgetown should make the NCAA tournament every year) was finally fired at the end of the 2003-04 season, under enormous pressure from alumni.

When Thompson took over, he inherited a program which had largely lost the interests of the students (in general, Georgetown hadn’t really been a major national power, since Iverson left in 1996), and had entirely lost the interest of the DC media market, always Redskins-obsessed. The stellar success of crosstown rival Maryland, in nearby College Park, became the focus of college basketball in the market. Georgetown just didn’t matter any more. And so his success in reviving the program – and doing it in such an innovative way – is really quite an achievement.

Thompson abolished the previous approach of his father and Esherick, of emphasizing defense over offense and a commitment to winning ugly. Instead – and moreover, doing it with players who had been recruited under Esherick – he installed the elegant Princeton offense, beautiful to watch but extremely unpleasant for opponents to face. In addition, it had the advantage of destroying the orthodoxy on how to beat Georgetown (which by 2004, the end of the Esherick regime, had spread throughout the entire conference). Every opponent had to discard their previous ideas on how to stop the Hoyas and adapt to facing the same players, but playing a radically different style, the basketball equivalent of being used to playing at the equator and suddenly having your game shifted to the South Pole.

What to Expect


The most instructive source for what will happen, is the previous game on January 8 at the Verizon Center. Villanova’s 56-52 victory was a throwback to the old Big East days of ugly ball, as the teams combined for an astonishing 39 turnovers (21 by Georgetown, 18 by Villanova; ‘Nova also had 11 steals, and steals are more likely to lead to easy baskets than other sorts of turnovers). The eventual Villanova victory can be attributed to three major factors, beyond the defense that forced 21 turnovers:

1) A superb 16-point effort by Scottie Reynolds, who as a freshman in the early part of the season, was not well known to the Georgetown coaching staff, who realistically underestimated the offensive threat he posed.


2) An equally superb 14-point outburst from Shane Clark, a sophomore who was used primarily as a defensive specialist during the 2005-06 season.

3) Finally, and most importantly, a clampdown on Roy Hibbert. This clampdown was the most effective of any Georgetown opponent this season. He was a complete non-factor on the offensive end. Hibbert played 24 minutes, and not due to foul trouble (he finished with only two fouls). In those 24 minutes, he never even had a field goal attempt (his two points came at the line), and grabbed only three rebounds.

Hibbert leads the nation in field goal percentage, shooting at over a 70% clip, and he didn’t even get a single shot that day. He was a presence on the defensive end with three blocks, but Georgetown was not able to get him the ball (when he gets no shots, it’s safe to say that Georgetown had no ability to integrate the low-post into their offense. The low number of rebounds – rebounds for big men generally come when short shots are missed – also reflects this fact.

For Georgetown, the star was Dajuan Summers, who finished with 16 points, four rebounds, and three assists. The only other Hoya who reached double figures was Jonathan Wallace, whose dozen points were partially offset by the fact that he committed a half-dozen turnovers and had only two assists.

Villanova Update

The Wildcats (6-5 Big East, 18-7 overall, CollegeRPI rank of #13 as of Sunday, February 11, 2007) are riding their own four-game winning streak into the contest. The emergence of Dante Cunningham (last year, as with fellow freshman Clark, he was used primarily as a defender, and would be shuttled in and out on defensive possessions in the end game) as an offensive force has helped propel the Wildcats off the bubble and into safe NCAA territory. His high field goal percentage has taken some of the burden off Curtis Sumpter, and given Villanova additional presence in the paint.

I’ll have a full recap after the game.

Questions? Comments? Information? You can contact Craig Dimitri by e-mailing
novaviewpoint@yahoo.com
.




Villanova/Georgetown Rivalry History


by Craig Dimitri
E-mail: novaviewpoint@yahoo.com

Saturday's game will be the 62nd meeting between Villanova and Georgetown. The Hoyas lead the all-time series, 34-27, and a comfortable 28-20 in Big East play, despite the fact that the Wildcats have captured eight of the last ten meetings, including the last three.
Villanova's legendary rivalry with Georgetown is truly remarkable. The greatest game in Villanova history took place on April 1, 1985, when the Wildcats defeated the heavily-favored Hoyas to capture the NCAA championship. For more on the traditions and rivalry, please keep reading...

At the end of this article, I will tell the story of the 1985 game, the most thrilling game I have ever seen, in any sport. But before I do so, I will describe the rise of the Hoya empire. Villanova's upset is fully appreciated, when one considers what the Wildcats had to face.

In marked contrast to Villanova, Georgetown had little basketball tradition, prior to the arrival of John Thompson in 1972. (As an undergraduate, I spent a semester studying at Georgetown, and so I am very familiar with Georgetown's history and traditions.)

First - The perennial question: "What Is A Hoya?"

I will quote the Georgetown media guide:

"In the days when all Georgetown students were required to study Greek and Latin, the University's teams were nicknamed "the Stonewalls". A student, using Greek and Latin terms, started the cheer, "Hoya Saxa", which translates as "What rocks!" The name proved popular and the term Hoyas was eventually adopted for all Georgetown teams.
Georgetown's colors are blue and gray, and the direct inspiration for them was the Civil War. During the war, Georgetown's location on the Potomac river placed it at the border between Union and Confederacy. Maryland and the District of Columbia were part of the Union. But Virginia, across the river, was the most populous and important state of the Confederacy. In addition to its location, many Georgetown alumni, the "sons of Georgetown", had fought for each side. (It was an all-male school at the time.)

In light of those facts, Georgetown decided to adopt blue and gray as its colors: the Union soldiers had worn blue uniforms while many Confederate armies had worn gray. Like the nation, the Georgetown community itself had been divided during the confict. The symbolism was intended as a healing gesture, to reunite after the war.

Thompson, a member of the College Basketball Hall of Fame, is a genuine legend. Due to his success and his powerful personality, he remains one of the best known college basketball coaches in America. However, Thompson's accomplishments are even more remarkable, in light of the Georgetown program which he inherited. Thompson literally constructed the Hoyas' program, brick by brick, for over a quarter of a century.

Georgetown's program is among the oldest in the nation. The Hoyas' first season (four games) was 1906-1907: the Hoyas played nearby George Washington three times, and one against Virginia. The program did enjoy some success during the 1920s, posting some strong records. However, the success predated both the NCAA tournament and the NIT.

Villanova traveled to Georgetown in the Wildcats' second season of play, 1921-22. But the Wildcats fell, 39-34. Surprisingly, due to the close proximity of the schools, the teams would not play again for 23 years!
In 1943, Georgetown qualified for postseason play, for the first time in school history. Led by Elmer Ripley, the Hoyas went 22-5 and qualified for the NCAA tournament, held at New York's Madison Square Garden that year. The talented Mr. Ripley must have been a great coach: at that time, the NCAA tourney invited only eight teams! Georgetown defeated New York University and DePaul to reach the national championship game. But Wyoming whipped the Hoyas, 46-34, to win the national championship. In the consolation game, Georgetown topped Toledo and thus finished in third place.

Unfortunately for Georgetown, its next two seasons were cancelled due to World War II. I speculate that due to the school's DC location, its building was commandeered for military use. For example, in Philadelphia, Penn's Palestra was used for Navy administrative offices. However, no Big Five team's schedule was cancelled due to the war.

After the war ended in 1945, Villanova and Georgetown began a spirited rivalry. Three months after the Japanese surrender, Villanova hosted the Hoyas for the first time. The Wildcats won, 40-37. For the next four years, they played each other twice a season, foreshadowing the twice-a-year rivalry in the BIG EAST. Georgetown swept Villanova in 1947, and the teams split the 1948 series. But Villanova swept the Hoyas, during the next two seasons.

For some reason, the series ended after the 1950 season. Three decades would ensue, before the creation of the BIG EAST in 1980. Surprisingly, the teams played each other only three times, over those 30 years.
In 1953, Georgetown made its first NIT appearance: it was still the era when the NIT was probably more prestigious than the NCAAs. The Hoyas went 13-7, and lost to Louisville in the first round. They wouldn't return to post-season play until 1970, earning another NIT bid and losing in the first round to Louisiana State.
Thompson arrived in DC, taking over for the 1972-73 season. He inherited a moribund Georgetown program, which had gone 3-23 the previous season. Georgetown's "tradition" was a grand total of three post-season appearances: two NIT bids and a NCAA third-place finish.

Naturally, nobody expected that Georgetown would become even a respectable program, let alone a powerhouse. The idea that the Hoyas would become one of the most prominent and successful teams in the nation was utterly absurd. But Thompson was the architect and visionary that made it possible.

In 1975, Thompson's third season, the Hoyas made their first trip to the NCAA tournament in 32 years. While Georgetown lost in the first round, it began one of the most remarkable streaks in college basketball. Since 1975, Georgetown has reached postseason play, every year, to the present day. During that span, Georgetown has received 20 NCAA bids and made six NIT appearances. The Hoyas won the 1984 national championship, and reached the Final Four in 1982 and 1985. Georgetown also has made four trips to the Elite Eight, the most recent in 1996, led by Allen Iverson.

Georgetown was one of the eight original members of the BIG EAST, in 1979-1980. Villanova joined as the ninth team, one year later. Villanova has continued to do well in the BIG EAST. But Villanova has a worse record against Georgetown, in BIG EAST games, than against any of the other eight original members.
That brings us to the miraculous game, on April 1, 1985, when Villanova beat Georgetown and captured the NCAA championship!

That season was the first year that the NCAA tournament consisted of 64 teams, up from 48. At 19-10, it was unclear as to whether Villanova would even receive a bid: the Wildcats received a #8 seed.

There is a consensus among national observers, that Villanova made the most unbelievable, miraculous run of any team in the NCAA tournament, before or since. The Wildcats defeated #9 seed Dayton on Dayton's home floor (teams are no longer permitted to play on their home floor.) Villanova then upset the #1 seed, Michigan, to head for the Sweet 16.

The Wildcats then flew to Birmingham, Alabama, and knocked off ACC powers Maryland and North Carolina. It was Villanova's first Final Four appearance since 1971, when the Wildcats lost to UCLA in the final. (Villanova's games were ultimately forfeited due to Howard Porter signing with an agent, prior to the tournament, rendering him ineligible.)

Two other BIG EAST teams, Georgetown and St. John's, joined 'Nova in Lexington, Kentucky. Villanova surprised Memphis State in the national semifinal, while Georgetown stopped St. John's. Georgetown was considered a virtual lock for the national title. The Hoyas were the defending national champions, and entered the game at 35-2. (Georgetown's only two losses had been to St. John's and Syracuse, by a total of three points.) Moreover, Georgetown had been routinely thrashing 'Nova since the Wildcats had entered the BIG EAST in 1981. The Hoyas had won nine of the eleven games in that span, many by convincing margins.

In 1985, there was only a slight glimmer of hope. Villanova had battled the Hoyas in two close losses that season: a 57-50 loss at Georgetown and a heartbreaking, 52-50 overtime loss at the Spectrum. Nonetheless, nobody other than Rollie and the Wildcats thought that they had a chance to come out on top.
College basketball observers everywhere agree that Villanova played "The Perfect Game," defeating the Hoyas, 66-64, to bring home the national championship to the Main Line! Villanova shot 22-27 from the floor, an unthinkable 78.6%. The Wildcats took only ten shots in the second half, making nine of them.

(At the original composition of this article, prior to the arrival of Jay Wright, I wrote that "I'm surprised that Villanova doesn't have an elaborate display in the Pavilion, regarding that season. There should be more than a single banner." Subsequently, under the Wright regime, a fitting and proper mural of the 1985 national championship team has been added to the ground floor of the Pavilion lobby. Nonetheless, there should be a mini-museum to tell the story. The mural was a good start, but more still needs to be done for proper commemoration.)

The best illustration of Georgetown's stature: Villanova played The Perfect Game - and only won by two!

More recently, there has been another Villanova victory over Georgetown to savor. On January 30 1999, Villanova pulled off a 93-90, double-overtime, miraculous win over Georgetown at the First Union Center. (I attended the game, and it was the most exciting finish that I've ever seen live.) In the second OT, we trailed 90-87, with five seconds to go. Georgetown was at the foul line. After the Hoya missed two shots, Howard Brown hit a three-pointer from the corner to tie the game with one second remaining. Georgetown carelessly inbounded the ball, it was stolen by Brooks Sales, and Jermaine Medley hit a three-pointer at the buzzer to win it...

Another worthwhile note: The Wildcats were the first opponent to play Georgetown at the new MCI (now Verizon) Center, in December 1997 - and won. Since then, they have never lost at Georgetown.

Questions? Comments? Information? You can contact Craig Dimitri at novaviewpoint@yahoo.com.


Thursday, February 15, 2007

Wildcats Blizzard Bearcats, 64-48, In Front of Student Crowd at Pavilion


By Craig Dimitri
E-mail:
novaviewpoint@yahoo.com

Valentine’s Day, 2007, was the first time the Cincinnati Bearcats had ever traveled to the Philadelphia region to play Villanova. They won’t want to come back any time soon, either for the weather outside the Pavilion, or the ferocious Villanova defense they encountered within it. Both indoors and outdoors, it was about as bad as it could be for a Villanova opponent.

The conditions were highly inhospitable: snow, sleet, wind, etc. And it was just as bad for the woeful Cincinnati Bearcats inside the snowed-in Pavilion. In front of a student-packed building, with regular-season-ticket holders kept snowbound by the ghastly wintry mix, Villanova crushed Cincinnati, 64-48, in a game that was far more lopsided, than the 16-point margin would indicate. (VU announced earlier that day that due to the weather, any student could present his/her WildCard and receive a free ticket for the game, since there would be quite a few no-shows among the non-student ticketholders.)

The Wildcats sent Cincinnati out with a gale force in the first half, gusting out to a 30-8 lead with less than five minutes to go in the first half. By intermission, the Wildcats had nine steals and had forced a dozen turnovers, while permitting the Bearcats only five field goals (on three assists), 15 shots, and 17 points. Villanova had Cincy doubled-up at halftime, 34-17, and that was with Curtis Sumpter and Dante Cunningham combining to score no points before the half. Instead, the star of the first half was Mike Nardi, who had already hit four triples and posted 14 of his eventual 16 points, by the halftime buzzer. The Wildcats coasted the rest of the way. Cunningham almost ended up with a double-double, anyhow, finishing the game with 11 points and nine rebounds.

Villanova won its fourth straight game, and now has won eight of its last 10. The Wildcats lifted their record to 6-5 Big East, 18-7 overall, and continued their February momentum – they haven’t lost since January 29 against Pittsburgh. The Bearcats have been going in the opposite direction, as they have now lost their last seven games. Cincinnati, which will soon be eliminated from contention for the dozen-team Big East tournament, fell to 1-10 Big East, 10-15 overall. It is likely to be the worst season at UC since the pre-Bob Huggins era, which lasted for 15 seasons before abruptly ending in August 2005.

The statistics do not show a large VU advantage in any area, but that was primarily because the game was really over, before it began. One of the many downsides to the bloated Big East, is the fact that the bottom quarter of the conference is going to reach the end of the road in about two and a half weeks. There was always the chance of redemption, before the expansion. No matter how bad your team was, you could always cling to the hope of getting hot in March and even if not winning the BE tournament, at least coming up with an upset and making your presence known to some opponent on the NCAA bubble. But for last-place Cincinnati, there is no such solace – there’s nothing to do but play out the string. Granted, they have only one senior and there’s nowhere to go but up. Nonetheless, this was a very unpleasant evening, during an entire season of unpleasantness for UC this year. (The stretch in the first half, where they went over 11 minutes without scoring…about as rough sledding as one can encounter…) The lone bright spot was John Williamson’s 15 points and five rebounds, the only Bearcat to reach double figures.

The annihilation was that much more surprising, because the Bearcats had performed well at Syracuse, Providence, and Rutgers, losing only narrowly at three of the toughest home courts in the conference. In addition, there was some genuine concern about the intensity level for the Wildcats – a late tip-time of 9 PM to accommodate ESPNU, a Pavilion without its usual throng of spectators due to the weather, and the inescapable fact that Cincinnati entered the game having lost six in a row and 11 of its last dozen contests. Despite all of those intensity-sapping factors, however, the Wildcats achieved exactly what Jay Wright needed: a big lead early, a chance to rest the key players and to get the bench players some minutes, all of which happened. One dozen Wildcats saw action in the game, which featured cameos from Casiem Drummond, Frank Tchuisi, Ross Condon, and even five minutes for Dwayne Anderson. Nobody played more than 29 minutes. Bilal Benn and St. Joseph’s Prep product Reggie Redding, both of whom are seeing increased minutes in the rotation, got 22 and 20 minutes respectively.

Next Up for the Wildcats

The showdown is looming with #14 Georgetown, which has won eight straight and seeks to avenge the defeat Villanova dealt them at the Verizon Center in Washington, back on Monday, January 8, 2007. Roy Hibbert scored just two points while GU committed 22 turnovers, highly favorable facts for Villanova but ones which are not likely to replicate themselves on Saturday at the Wachovia Center.

I’ll have a full preview of the big showdown, plus an updated history of the Villanova/Georgetown rivalry.

Questions? Comments? Information? You can contact Craig Dimitri at
novaviewpoint@yahoo.com.


Tuesday, February 13, 2007

Preview of Cincinnati @ Villanova, the Pavilion, February 14, 2007, 9 PM


By Craig Dimitri
E-mail:
novaviewpoint@yahoo.com

The Wildcats will face the Cincinnati Bearcats on Valentine’s Day, 2007, at 9:00 PM at the Pavilion. A comprehensive preview…

The Viewpoint on the Cincinnati Bearcats

Coach: Mick Cronin - 79-37 (4th season) career record at Murray State and UC, record @ UC (1st season), 10-14.

For those of you who were used to seeing the casually dressed Bob Huggins on the Cincinnati sideline (he of the notorious 0% graduation rate), there’s a new sheriff in town. An alumnus of UC, Cronin spent seven years at UC as a recruiting assistant coach, prior to being named head coach at nearby Murray State in Kentucky, where he spent three seasons.

Huggins, the long-time UC coach, resigned after being given an ultimatum to do so or be fired, on August 26, 2005. He had spent 15 years at UC, winning 399 games. Huggins’ Bearcats remained wildly successful, despite being stuck in a wildly volatile conference alignment, during the earthquakes of the last 15 years among conferences. UC is currently playing in its fourth conference, in the last 16 years. It formerly resided in the Metro, Great Midwest, and Conference USA, and finally, wound up in its current home in the Big East, now in its second season. (Villanova has been in the Big East for the last quarter-century, in contrast.)

With the coaching carousel at its normal late-summer halt, Cincinnati had to use stopgap measures, and so associate head coach (and recruiting assistant) Andy Kennedy was named interim head coach for the 2005-06 season. Kennedy had a decent season, going 21-13 overall during UC’s first journey in the Big East. They came close to making the NCAA tournament. Cincinnati ended up garnering a #1 seed in the NIT, and taking the Bearcats to the quarterfinals, where they lost to South Carolina, the eventual repeat champion of the tournament. (It was the first time since St. John’s did it during World War II, when the NIT was the premier tournament, that anyone had won back-to-back NITs.) Kennedy was young, a 1991 graduate of Alabama-Birmingham (UAB), where he played for three seasons, after initially playing for Jim Valvano at NC State.

The 34-year-old Cronin was named head coach at UC on March 23, 2006; Cronin had coached the Racers at age 31, an incredibly young age for a Division I head coach. A search committee had been created, and Kennedy was publicly announced as a candidate to have “interim” removed from his position, but UC ultimately decided to replace Kennedy with Cronin (a Cincinnati native, in addition to being an alumnus).

At first, Cronin served as an assistant coach at Louisville, before becoming head coach at Murray State. The young coach was highly successful at Murray State, a perennial sleeper choice in NCAA tournament brackets – he took the Racers to the Big Dance twice in his three seasons there. However, the UC he left and the UC to which he returned do not resemble each other, as we shall see below. During Cronin’s seven years as a UC assistant, the Bearcats went 108-26, won the now-defunct Conference USA regular-season championship five times, in addition to winning the C-USA tournament twice. (It’s only mid-February of his first season, and he has already seen 14 losses – the Bearcats only had 28 for his entire seven-season apprenticeship).

2006-07 Season Analysis - 1-9 Big East – 16th place, 10-14 overall, RPI rank #166, as of the end of Sunday, February 11, 2007

Schedule and Results

Last season, 2005-06, the Bearcats were a good, solid team, becoming a NIT quarterfinalist team, and finishing 21-13 last year (including the NIT games). That was a decent team, especially for one playing in a new, unfamiliar conference. At the end of the regular season, the Bearcats finished a respectable 8-8 in conference play and 19-11 overall, and sat squarely on the bubble for the NCAA tournament. When the Bearcats lost by one point to Syracuse in New York, however, their NCAA hopes died with the loss. They won two games in the NIT before running into South Carolina.

Unfortunately, entering this season of 2006-07, the Bearcats were returning only one starter - and only two players who had seen significant minutes – from that 21-13 team of a year ago. Accordingly, Cronin brought in a gargantuan recruiting class of nine players, to try to build up some sandbags for what was widely anticipated to be a very difficult season for Cincinnati. These anticipations were correct – after getting off to a decent start in the remainder of 2006, the Bearcats nosedived around New Year’s Eve and have yet to recover.


It did not help matters that the two tallest players in that nine-man recruiting class were declared ineligible - one of whom can never be eligible and a second who will only be eligible after sitting out the 2006-07 season. These ineligibility issues contribute to Cincinnati's problematic lack of depth.

In light of the team’s near-total lack of experience – and playing in one of the toughest conferences in America - Cincinnati played a reasonably difficult non-Big East schedule. Jerry Palm currently rates their strength-of-schedule – SOS – at a respectable 53.

The Bearcats’ season started well enough, easily winning the Jim Thorpe Classic, an eight-team tournament in November. The quality of opponents – Howard, Tennessee-Martin, and High Point – was extremely low, as is indicated by the fact that Cincinnati won all three games by double-digit margins. But three wins are still three wins and something upon which to build.

The season began to unravel with a one-point loss to Wofford at home in the fourth game. Cincinnati managed to get past two easy home games against Central Michigan and Oakland and stood at 5-1 entering December, albeit against six cupcakes.

When Cincinnati began facing the serious part of its nonconference schedule, the team’s record started to erode. The Bearcats took on a half-dozen reasonably competent opponents: UAB (a loss to Kennedy’s alma mater), Temple and Xavier (wins over both Atlantic 10 schools, the latter coming in the Crosstown Shootout against the Jesuit school in Cincinnati), a pounding at the hands of ranked Ohio State in the Wooden Tradition, and wins over NC State and Miami/Ohio. The victory over the “other” Miami on December 27 was the high point of the Bearcats’ season – their record stood at 9-3 overall, with nonconference games against Memphis and Ohio University remaining before Big East play.

However, the roof caved in on the Bearcats, from that point forward. They have a solitary win, over the course of their last dozen games. The game @ Memphis was a disastrous 33-point loss, followed by a stunning 13-point loss to the “other” Ohio. Big East play has been an utter nightmare for the Bearcats. The season opening games, at home vs. Rutgers and @ South Florida, resulted in a dozen-point defeat to RU (in what were probably the two easiest conference game they’ll have all year), in which the Bearcats managed to score only 42 points, and a 15-point loss @ USF.

There was a brief revival of quality play during the following week in January. Within four days, they played Syracuse surprisingly tight at the Carrier Dome, but lost by a single point – and defeated a quality opponent in West Virginia, in a rare double-digit OT win, 96-83. There might have been some reason for optimism at that point. Their record was 1-3 Big East, 10-8 overall, and with some luck they might manage to finish in the top 12 and make the Big East tournament.


Unfortunately for the Bearcats, that window in January slammed shut as quickly as it opened. They have lost every game since the OT win over WVU on January 20 – a six-game losing streak which has sunk them to the dank abyss of the Big East standings at 1-9, 10-14. One bright spot – after four blowout losses, the Bearcats played competently in their two most recent games. On February 6, they threw a scare into the Friars @ Providence, losing by one, and in the rematch @ the RAC on February 10, Rutgers won by just four. How such a terrible team could go into those places – among the toughest homecourts in the league – and almost win is inexplicable.

However, they have no prayer of reaching the Big East tournament at this point. They are three full games behind Connecticut, the current 12th seed, with six games remaining, and three other schools to jump over as well. In addition, there is only a single game left on their schedule, that they could be considered to have even a 50/50 chance of winning. Their remaining games are @ Villanova, hosting nationally-ranked Notre Dame and Georgetown, @ DePaul, and the rematch @ West Virginia, which just toppled UCLA in Morgantown. The home game against Seton Hall – February 28, Senior Night - is probably the only winnable one, and the Bearcats will still be an underdog. Also, by then they’ll have been mathematically eliminated from the BE tournament, anyhow.

In summary, Cincinnati has lost 11 of its last 12 and hasn’t won a true road game the entire season, Big East or otherwise, although they did come close @ Syracuse, Providence, and Rutgers.

Cincinnati Starters/Rotation

Cincinnati uses only six players (of the rest of the team, nobody else averages more than 9 minutes/game). And so the half-dozen-man rotation is really all we need to consider.



Starters

#5 Deonta Vaughn - 6-1 - Freshman - Guard - 14.3 points/3.5 rebounds/3.6 assists/2.3 turnovers/1.7 steals/32.2 min per game (Indianapolis, IN)

The team’s point guard and minutes leader, who takes more shots from the floor than any of his teammates. In particular, Vaughn takes a boatload of three-point shots every game (he averages over seven 3FGA per contest), but unfortunately for Cincy, he’s not all that accurate: he shoots only 31.8% from that range. Has a decent assist-to-turnover ratio.

#33 Jamual Warren - 6-2 - Jr - Guard - 8.7 points/3.9 rebounds/3.3 assists/2.4 turnovers/2.0 steals/29.5 min per game (Springfield, MA)

For a guard, he’s a terrible free throw shooter (59.3%) and perimeter marksman (14%!?!), although fortunately for Cincinnati, he doesn’t attempt many threes. He can dish the ball as well as steal it, and does OK, “rebound-wise”, for a guard, which compensates somewhat for his inaccurate shots.

#10 Marcus Sikes - 6-8 - Jr - Forward - 10.5 points/5.2 rebounds/1.5 assists/30.4 min per game (Richmond, VA, via Mt. San Jacinto College)

Sikes, along with John Williamson, is one of two Bearcats to start all 24 games, and also one of three Bearcats to average in double figures, is the team’s only significant perimeter threat, making 42.7% of his shots from that distance. As with Williamson, below, he averages three fouls a game.

#45 - John Williamson 6-6 - Jr - Forward- 12.8 points/7.3 rebounds/1.0 assists/30.8 min per game (Columbus, OH)

Has started all 24 games. An effective rebounder, he averages over 3.4 just on the offensive end. Also has a tendency to fall into foul trouble, averaging over three fouls a game, and since the Bearcats have no depth, that’s a significant weakness. He’s a poor foul shooter, connecting on only 56.7% of his attempts – another weakness because he’s the Bearcat who most often reaches the foul line.

#30 Cedric McGowan - 6-7 - Sr - Forward - 8.3 points/5.2 rebounds/0.6 blocks/29.2 min per game (Miami, FL )

McGowan is the only senior who plays significantly. A good rebounder and interior defender, as well as a good foul shooter (75.5%), for a frontcourt player. Also can block a shot occasionally.

Off the Bench

#1 Marvin Gentry - 6-3 - Jr - Guard - 7.9 points/2.7 rebounds/1.3 assists/25.2 min per game (Ft. Worth, TX via McLennan JC)

The team’s sixth man and only significant bench player, Gentry has also started seven games this season. A junior-college transfer who was undoubtedly brought in to bolster Cincinnati’s virtually nonexistent bench.

Overall Analysis of the Bearcats

With only one senior in the rotation, the Bearcats will probably be better next season, particularly since after this one is over, there will be nowhere to go but up. This game, along with the Senior Day game against Rutgers on February 24, is one of only two that could be NCAA-tournament-fatal for Villanova with a loss. A home loss to a team ranked #166 in the RPI – in February – would be devastating for the Wildcats’ tournament hopes. Even winning the game will probably lower VU’s relative standing in the RPI, as UC’s #166 is then added into the formula as an opponent. Nonetheless, the Bearcats’ surprising ability to be competitive on the road, in three tough environments (note the narrow losses @ Syracuse, @ Providence, and @ Rutgers), means that the game cannot be taken as an automatic “W”, even when facing the 16th-place team in the conference.

Series History

This is Cincinnati’s first road trip to the Philadelphia area to play Villanova, in any of the assorted venues (Jake Nevin Field House, the Palestra, the Pavilion, the old Spectrum, the Wachovia Center) that the Wildcats have called home, over the decades. Villanova and Cincinnati have only played each other twice, which is not surprising since they aren’t near each other and played in different conferences until last season. The Wildcats have won both meetings, both in Cincinnati, by two points. The first took place on December 20, 1947, in Cincinnati, with the visiting Wildcats – under Alexander Severance – won 70-68. (That was a real shootout in that era, with no shot clock and no three-point line.)

The schools’ paths wouldn’t cross again for another 59 years, until Cincinnati joined the Big East. However, Wright and the Wildcats remember all too well what happened @ Cincinnati last year, when the high-flying, #2 Wildcats sailed into the Bearcat lair at Fifth Third Arena (the highest-ranked team ever to play there). In the schools’ first and only Big East meeting thus far. took a brilliantly conceived Dante Cunningham layup with 3.2 seconds remaining, to escape with a 74-72 victory and extend the team’s winning streak to 11 games.

Philadelphia Big Five fans may remember this oddity:

During the 1990s, a bizarre, de facto rivalry began between Temple and Cincinnati. There was no logic to it, as to why they would meet so often, but the teams kept doing so perennially. The Owls and Bearcats faced each other no fewer than nine times, from December 1992 through February 2000, including three NCAA tournaments in a five-year span. Two of those were consecutive tournaments - 1995 and 1996. Moreover, in both of those years, they had already faced each other, during the regular season. This took place in spite the NCAA Selection Committee’s generally-observed bracketing rule, which stipulates attempts to avoid both regular-season rematches, as well as rematches from the previous year’s NCAA tournament. (Remember, UC hadn’t played Villanova since 1947, while all of this was going on.)

And in what is probably even more unusual – Cincinnati swept the first six of those nine games – the Bearcats won every meeting from December 1992 through the 1996 NCAA tournament. At first, the Bearcats dominated the rivalry (granted, they were ranked #1 in the polls at one point during that span), even though Temple had some great seasons during the 1990s. Naturally, after being defeated six straight times by the Bearcats, former Temple coach John Chaney vented publicly about “how I’m sick of losing to Cincinnati.” The Owls did turn the tables, eventually, winning the last three games against the Bearcats, which took place in January 1997, the 1999 NCAA tournament, and February 2000. The teams hadn’t met since then, until this season, battling in Atlantic City, NJ. It was much closer to Temple, obviously, just 60 miles from Philadelphia, but it was officially on a neutral court. The Bearcats broke their skid against the Owls, with a victory in December 2006.

Cincinnati is one of the most venerable institutions in college basketball, a generation older than Villanova’s program, which started in the 1920-21 season. Cincinnati began its program at the dawn of the twentieth century, fielding its first team in the 1901-02 season, and so its program is an incredible 106 years old. That 1901-02 team went 5-4, paving the way for a winning tradition which has included a slew of All-Americans and NBA players, with the most famous being “The Big O”, Oscar Robertson, one of the greatest players of all time.

What to Expect

Jay Wright would undoubtedly love to build up a big lead, getting Curtis Sumpter, Mike Nardi, and Scottie Reynolds out of the game early – thus giving some of his bench players (especially Bilal Benn and Casiem Drummond) a chance for some minutes, should they be needed in games of more significance. With snow looming over the Philadelphia area, it’s very possible that the Pavilion will be far more student-dominated than usual and the Bearcats will be facing a tougher home crowd than that which would ordinarily greet the Big East’s cellar-dwelling team on the road.

This game is a tune-up for what will be an extremely difficult three-day span over the weekend, facing two formidable teams: Georgetown arrives at the Wachovia Center at noon on Saturday – after which, the Wildcats must immediately board a plane to Milwaukee and take on the Golden Eagles at 7:00 PM in a Big Monday matchup on ESPN.

Villanova Update

The Wildcats (5-5 Big East, 16-7 overall, RPI rank #13) are coming off an unattractive road victory at unimpressive Seton Hall, one which they made unexpectedly uncomfortable after building a sizable lead at halftime. They have won their last three games and are developing momentum in February, as we enter the stretch run of the season.

I’ll have a full recap after the game.

Questions? Comments? Information? You can contact Craig Dimitri by e-mailing
novaviewpoint@yahoo.com.


Saturday, February 10, 2007

Villanova, Sumpter Sink Pirates, 78-69, In Foul-Marred Duel to the Death


By Craig Dimitri
E-mail:
novaviewpoint@yahoo.com

It was probably Villanova’s ugliest game of the season, a marathon battle of attrition which took well over two hours to decide, with heavy casualties on both sides. But the Wildcats eventually sank the Pirate Ship, 78-69, sending Seton Hall careening with its fifth straight Big East defeat. The Pirates are rapidly sinking to the bottom of the Big East ocean, falling to 3-7 Big East, 12-11 overall, and are not likely to finish in the top dozen of the 16-team league, thus missing the Big East tournament.
In contrast, Villanova improved to 5-5 Big East, 16-7 overall. The Wildcats are now mathematically assured of their ninth consecutive winning season and postseason bid (in the last eight seasons, Villanova has been to three NCAA tournaments and five NITs). Villanova has now sunk the Pirate Ship, in its last five pitched battles with Seton Hall.

The Pirate Ship’s sinking was primarily due to the heavy casualties, which their crew absorbed during the battle. Four Pirates were disqualified and two others finished with four fouls. Another Pirate had announced his decision to renounce his buccaneer status: the senior forward Mani Messy simply quit the team on Wednesday. With such a shorthanded crew, Seton Hall was unable to sustain the contest, and Villanova was not seriously threatened at crunch time. The Pirates were no match for the Wildcats on the glass, as Villanova pounded the Pirates on the boards by a greater than 2-1 margin, 41-20. Also, the Wildcats actually increased their Big-East-leading free-throw accuracy, shooting 34-41 from the line (83%). The big cannon for Villanova were – as is so often the case – seniors Curtis Sumpter and Mike Nardi. But a third heavy gun unexpectedly entered the fray: Dante Cunningham.

It was a typically superb afternoon for Sumpter: 21 points on 7-13 shooting, along with 10 rebounds for yet another double-double. Nardi had 16 points, with 11 of them coming from the free throw line, where he excels, shooting at an 88% clip; he was down a little bit, actually, going “just” 11-15 from the stripe. Nardi also dealt eight assists and grabbed four rebounds. But Cunningham’s offensive explosion was the stunner: 14 points on 4-7 shooting from the floor, and 6-7 from the line. All of these points came (along with a pair of rebounds and a block) in only 26 minutes of action. The greatest play was when he dunked over Pirate John Garcia in the second half, probably the most spectacular play of his Wildcat career.

Scottie Reynolds was mired in foul trouble, and so played only 23 minutes, making just one of his half-dozen field goal attempts. But he still reached double figures with 11 points, going 9-9 from the line, dealing four assists and pulling down four rebounds as well. Reggie Redding, the freshman from St. Joseph’s Prep in Philadelphia, continued to shine coming off the bench: eight points on 4-8 shooting, and half a dozen rebounds (four on the offensive end) in just 23 minutes.

For Seton Hall, Jamar Nutter matched Sumpter point-for-point, also hitting blackjack at 21 points on 7-14 shooting. Two other Pirates contributed 15 points: Eugene Harvey and Larry Davis.

The second-half battle was unexpectedly fierce, as Villanova had cruised to an easy 43-27 lead at intermission. The Wildcats appeared capable of quickly disposing the “outlaws of the seas”, and returning to the safe harbor of the Pavilion unscathed. Sumpter already had accumulated 16 points and seven rebounds, and perhaps the bench players could see some increased playing time.

The key story line was the Wildcats’ capture of the Pirates’ best player, Brian Laing. He entered the game averaging 16.6 points and 6.6 rebounds per contest. At halftime, he had been held scoreless, with two fouls. Pirate Captain Bobby Gonzalez did not return Laing to the floor to begin the second half, not inserting him until several minutes later, and Laing immediately committed his third foul. Laing eventually fouled out without scoring a single point, going 0-5 from the floor, with two rebounds and three assists in 24 minutes (he averages over 36 minutes a contest). “All Pirates, let ye be warned”: don’t mess with the Villanova defensive scheme, or meet a similar fate – i.e., becoming a nonfactor in the contest.

Villanova’s increasing problem in the second half was protecting the ball, as Seton Hall was able to plunder it from Villanova’s possession 18 times, ten of them in the second half. The Pirates turned over their treasure, so to speak, only eight times, and the turnover disparity was what kept the Pirates in the battle for so long. In addition, their long-range guns started to fire more accurately: the Pirates finished the contest shooting 9-19 from three-point range, 47%.

'Nova Notes

Will Sheridan’s minutes have now held steady in the teens, in each of the last three games. The senior played just 18 minutes today, finishing with four points, four rebounds, and three blocked shots, making significant contributions on defense. Bilal Benn played nine minutes and still managed to commit four fouls, five days after fouling out against St. Joseph’s at the Pavilion. Dwayne Anderson and Casiem Drummond each made cameo appearances of a single minute.

Series History

Villanova has now defeated Seton Hall five straight times overall, improving to 6-12 all-time at the Meadowlands. The Pirates haven’t successfully boarded Villanova since February 21, 2004, three seasons ago. After winning the 96th clash between the ancient rivals, the Wildcats now lead all-time, 59-37.

Next Up for the Wildcats


The Wildcats return to the Pavilion on Valentine’s Day, Wednesday, February 14, 2007, for a chance to easily defeat Cincinnati, the one-time powerhouse which is now among the weakest programs in the league. Tip-off is at an atypical 9:00 PM; I’ll have a full preview as game day approaches.

Questions? Comments? Information? You can contact Craig Dimitri at
novaviewpoint@yahoo.com.

Friday, February 09, 2007

Preview of Villanova @ Seton Hall, Saturday, February 10, 2007, noon


By Craig Dimitri
E-mail:
novaviewpoint@yahoo.com

The Viewpoint on the Seton Hall Pirates


Coach: Bobby Gonzalez – career record 141-87 (eighth year), SHU record 12-10 (first year)

Gonzalez is the 18th man to take the helm at Seton Hall, and is currently commanding his maiden voyage from South Orange, as Captain of the Pirate Ship. It’s been a very tumultuous voyage, as we shall see below.

Gonzalez was hired to replace former Syracuse star Louis Orr, who was forced to walk the plank after the 2005-06 season, after five seasons. Orr's final team qualified for the NCAA tournament as a #10 seed in 2006, losing to #7 Wichita State in the first round. Gonzalez had been in the coaching buzz for quite a while, due to his success during his seven-year-stint at nearby Manhattan (ironically, the same stepping stone that former Villanova coach Steve Lappas used to catapult himself into his nine-year tenure as head coach on the Main Line). It was widely believed that Gonzalez would end up somewhere in the Big East someday, and that speculation turned out to be accurate. He is from a Big East coaching tree, having served on Pete Gillen’s staff for four years at Providence from 1994-98. Gonzalez was a protégé of Gillen, also serving on his staff at non-Big East schools Xavier and Virginia (those stops bookended Gillen’s time at PC). He has a reputation for being an outstanding recruiter, particularly in the New York metropolitan area.

2006-07 Season Analysis of the Pirates
(3-6 Big East, 13th place, 12-10 overall, #121 RPI, #68 Strength-of-schedule as of games completed at the end Super Bowl Sunday, February 4, 2007, as compiled by Jerry Palm’s CollegeRPI.com)


Seton Hall, simply put, is not a very good team this year. The Pirates head into Saturday’s game with Villanova having lost four Big East games in a row, with the only interruption being a nonconference rout of down-the-NJ-Turnpike Princeton on January 29, 2007. The Pirates will be lucky to stagger home at .500 and receive a NIT bid, and consequently qualify for the Big East tournament with a 12th-place or better finish. If the tournament started today, the Pirates would be marooned, their season over.

Nonconference Schedule

SHU opened the year with a rout of non-Division I Caldwell, so their genuine record is only 11-10. They played an OK nonconference schedule, and still lost four games. Virginia Tech (RPI #33) and BYU (#29) were good losses; Oral Roberts (#104) and nearby Fairleigh Dickinson (#185) – at home, no less – were not. Their chances for an at-large NCAA bid are nil. The Pirates did achieve the rare feat of playing both Penn and Penn State in the same year, winning both games. They also beat St. Mary’s (#149) in double overtime.

Big East Play

SHU’s three conference wins have all come at home: a blowout of St. John’s, and two narrow wins over Rutgers and Providence (at #50 RPI, their best win of the season, in or out of the Big East). It’s worth noting that the Pirates had some resilience; Providence utterly destroyed the Pirate Ship up at the Dunkin’ Donuts Center, 91-69, on January 6, 2007. But eleven days later, the Hall held off the Friars by a single point at the Meadowlands. As for their half-dozen Big East losses – five of them have been by double-digits. The only single-digit loss was to in-state rival Rutgers, who avenged their defeat at the Meadowlands, by beating the Hall in double overtime at the RAC.

Seton Hall Pirates Starters/Rotation

Starters

#15 Eugene Harvey - 6/0 - Point Guard - Freshman - 16.0 points/3.2 rebounds/4.3 assists in 35.0 minutes (Brooklyn, NY)

Harvey has had a powerful impact as a freshman, as he is a leading candidate for Big East Rookie of the Year honors. He has already been named BE rookie-of-the-week three times, something matched only by Notre Dame’s Luke Harangody. Harvey has started all 22 games this season – very unusual for a freshman point guard in the Big East.

Harvey averages 4.3 assists versus 3.0 turnovers, as well as 1.7 steals. But he doesn’t just run the point – he’s one of Seton Hall’s top two scorers, along with Brian Laing, and he plays a lot of minutes. As is often the case for a point guard, he’s an outstanding foul shooter (82.6%). The one significant gap in his game is as a three-point threat: Harvey is shooting a dreadful 21.4%, from beyond the arc. This will permit Villanova to take their chances with Harvey’s outside shooting, and instead concentrate on stopping other perimeter threats.

#22 Paul Gause - 5/11 - Guard - Sophomore - 9.0 points/3.6 rebounds/1.6 assists in 24.9 minutes (Pittsgrove, NJ)

Jamar Nutter actually averages far more playing time, over 31 minutes. Gause takes a lot of three-point shots, but with poor accuracy: he averages only 29.1% from that range. However, Gause is also an outstanding defensive player, leading the Big East in steals at 3.23 thefts/game. He also can fall into foul trouble, as a result of such aggressiveness on defense. Gause averages over three fouls a contest, and the Pirate crew is sufficiently shorthanded with a seven-man rotation, that it’s important that he stay on the floor.#35 Larry Davis - 6/3 - Guard - Freshman – 8.3 points/3.7 rebounds/1.6 assists in 20.8 minutes (Middle Village, NY)
Davis plays – by far - the fewest minutes of the five starters, with Nutter surpassing him as well. Davis has made just eight starts this season. He is a highly dangerous threat from three-point range, shooting 45.6%, as well as 85% from the free-throw line.

#14 Brian Laing - 6/5 – Guard/Forward - Junior - 16.6 points/6.6 rebounds in 36.2 minutes (Bronx, NY)

Laing is the Pirates’ best player, leading the team in scoring, rebounding, and minutes. He is a mild threat from three-point range, shooting 31% from beyond the arc.

#23 Stan Gaines - 6/7 – Forward - Senior - 6.3 points/4.5 rebounds in 25.4 minutes (Chicago, IL)

Gaines has started all but three of SHU’s games this year. He is an accurate three-point shooter at 40%, and also ranks second in rebounds. However, he is also prone to fall into foul trouble, averaging 3.4 personal fouls a contest.

Off the Bench

#2 Jamar Nutter - 6/2 - Guard - Junior – 12.4 points/3.3 rebounds/2.1 assists in 31.1 minutes/game (Bloomfield, NJ – Seton Hall Prep)

Nutter is not listed among the probable starters by SHU, but Nutter has in fact started 17 of SHU’s 22 contests this season. Accordingly, his minutes rank third on the team, significantly outlogging Gause, Gaines, and David, all of whom are listed among the starters. He is the leading scorer among Pirates still around from last season’s voyage, the final journey under Orr.

#31 John Garcia - 6/9 – Forward/Center - Freshman - 4.5 points/2.0 rebounds in 11.8 minutes/game (Bayshore, NY)

Garcia has been plagued with significant injuries, since he arrived in South Orange. Garcia missed all of 2005-06 (taking a medical redshirt) and the first 16 games of this season due to his need to recover from knee surgery. His numbers reflect only the half-dozen games he’s participated in since his return.

Worth Noting – An 8th Player


#33 Grant Billmeier - 6/10 – Center - Senior – 3.4 points/3.4 rebounds in 13.8 minutes/game (Pennington, NJ)

We won’t see Billmeier at all, since he’s out for the season with an injury. However, his absence is worth noting because it is one fewer big man for Gonzalez to have available. Billmeier was important, as he started 10 of the 13 games he participated in, prior to his season-ending injury.

Overall Analysis of the Pirates

Villanova will be facing a Seton Hall team, which is rebuilding its foundation under a new coach. As with all regime changes, Gonzalez is now forced to coach players, the vast majority of whom he didn’t recruit and who may not fit well in his coaching philosophy and/or his personality. Seton Hall is also plagued with injuries, with Billmeier out for the season, Garcia coming back from a year and a half out with an injury. Two days ago, there was also the sudden departure of senior Mani Messy on Wednesday, February 7, with no official specification as to why, other than the announcement itself from Gonzalez of the mere fact that Messy is no longer with the program. Messy’s messy departure won’t make things any worse than they already are, but he did average over six minutes/game and it’s yet another body Gonzalez no longer has among his depleted ranks.

Seton Hall can match ‘Nova in one area – the Pirates are second only to the Wildcat in free throw accuracy, among Big East teams. They play a more uptempo style, and as a result, SHU both scores and allows more points than Villanova. With Billmeier out of the picture, this will be a rare Big East contest for Villanova, where they won’t have to contend with an imposing, bigger post player with their quicker, nimbler team. Seton Hall isn’t really any bigger than ‘Nova, and that would certainly work to ‘Nova’s advantage. The Hall only has seven Pirates to man the ship, two of whom have a serious propensity for foul trouble, chasing faster players.

The problem for Villanova recently has been offense - they’ve won their last two games against Louisville and St. Joseph’s by scoring just 57 and 56 points, respectively. Villanova’s guard-heavy team tends to rely on the three-point shot, and if they aren’t falling, it’s difficult for Villanova to make up for it by feeding the low post. In addition, the team’s best post player, Will Sheridan, did not play much in either of the last two games. However, it was not immediately clear, why Jay Wright had suddenly decided to limit the senior forward’s minutes sharply over the course of the past week (previously, he had logged almost as many minutes as anyone else in the rotation.) Another story has been the sudden rise in stock of freshman Reggie Redding, from St. Joseph’s Prep in Philadelphia. Redding’s been seeing a lot more court time recently.

The Pirates, even with a shorthanded crew, do have a very potent offense and scoring in the 50s is not going to be enough to beat them. It also happens to be bad luck that Villanova is happening to visit during “Spirit Week”, in which the SHU student body redoubles its efforts to fill the huge Meadowlands venue with Pirate fans.

Villanova/Seton Hall Series History

Seton Hall is one of Villanova’s most ancient rivals, not surprisingly for two Catholic schools separated by a short distance. This will be the 96th meeting between the two schools. Villanova has won the last four clashes, and leads all-time, 58-37. During the 2005-06 season, the schools met only once, at the Pavilion on January 17, 2006- the Wildcats won 73-64. Seton Hall’s last triumph was at the Meadowlands, winning a close one, 70-68, on February 21, 2004.

At the Meadowlands, Villanova is just 5-12, all-time.


Villanova Update

The Wildcats (4-5 Big East, 15-7 overall) are coming off a glorious Holy War trouncing of St. Joseph’s, sweeping the Big Five for the second consecutive year. There will undoubtedly be many Villanova fans at the game, given the vast seating available at the Meadowlands, its location in the heart of Villanova alumni country, and its proximity to campus. They may even outnumber the Seton Hall fans there.

For Villanova, the magic number is four – the number of BE wins needed to get to .500 and probably assure them of a reasonably weak opening round tournament game in New York and an at-large NCAA bid. This game at Seton Hall is undoubtedly being banked as one of those four.


I'll have a full recap after the game.

Questions? Comments? Information? You can contact Craig Dimitri at novaviewpoint@yahoo.com.

Wednesday, February 07, 2007

Villanova Defense Devastates Hawks, 56-39 – SJU’s Fewest Points in Holy War in 68 Years – 'Cats Sweep City Series for 2nd Straight Year

By Craig Dimitri
E-mail:
novaviewpoint@yahoo.com

Coach Jay Wright’s Wildcats used devastating defense, to suffocate the Hawks’ offense on Tuesday, February 6, 2007, at the Pavilion. They allowed a paltry 39 points, while forcing 21 St. Joseph’s turnovers. The 39 points were the fewest SJU has scored in a Holy War since – coincidentally – 1939, when Villanova crushed St. Joseph’s, 36-8. (It’s safe to say that particular record will never be surpassed!) So this is the de facto record-setter for Villanova defense, in the Big Five era, which started just over a half-century ago.)

It is a Holy War which deserves mention in the annals of the rivalry, due to the City-Series-record-setting Villanova defense. The superlatives are outstanding to categorize:

The Hawks shot just 26% from the floor – an easy-to-calculate 13-50. They were even worse from beyond the arc, shooting just 21% (3-14).

In scoring just 39 points, no Hawk reached double figures. The team leaders in points were starting guard Garrett Williamson, and a bench player, Darrin Govens, who scored eight points apiece. (Williamson nearly had a double-double, with ten rebounds).

Obviously, the Villanova defense deserves no credit for this shortcoming, but the Hawks were an abysmal 10-22 (46%) from the free throw line, one of the reasons why they scored just 39 points.

That having been said, the SJU defense was very formidable in its own right. On an ordinary evening, it probably would have doomed the Wildcats to defeat. Villanova scored only 56 points, matching its season low (the previous two 56s were in a loss @ West Virginia, and a win @ Georgetown). Moreover, it came on the heels of the 57-point output in the Wachovia Center victory against Louisville on Saturday, February 3, 2007. The Wildcats also committed 18 turnovers. Of course, there aren’t many games in this era, where 56 points and 18 turnovers propel a rout of the opponent, but that was the case on Tuesday night. This fact is a testament to the ferocity of the Wildcat defense.

For Villanova, the pair of standouts were seniors, playing in their final City Series contest: Curtis Sumpter and Mike Nardi. In only 30 minutes, Sumpter finished with 14 points on 6-11 shooting, seven rebounds, a pair of assists and three blocked shots. (Almost all of those numbers came in the first half – by intermission, Sumpter already had a dozen points and five rebounds.)

Nardi, playing 37 minutes, ended up with 11 points on just 3-12 shooting, but also dealt seven assists (one more than the entire Hawk team, which had just six!) Sophomore Shane Clark also provided a significant contribution, narrowly missing a double-double with nine points and eight rebounds in just 28 minutes (had he played a little more, he almost certainly would have gotten the double-double).

Aside from the lack of offensive output, the only annoyance of the contest, was the fact that SJU was able to backdoor some spectacular dunks, embarrassing the Villanova defense on those lobs. Had the game been closer, those defensive lapses would have been properly cited, as a potential impediment to victory. Fortunately, since the Hawks weren’t really in the contest, right from the opening-tip, those dunks didn’t matter (although they were good highlight-reel footage.).

Villanova improved to 4-0 Big Five, 16-7 overall; SJU fell to 2-1 Big Five, 13-10 overall. The 39 points were the lowest any Villanova opponent had scored this season, and also represented only the second time a Wildcat opponent had scored fewer than 50 points.


Two Surprises – Reggie Redding and Bilal Benn

Redding has begun to emerge as a key member of the Wildcats’ rotation, in recent games. A product of St. Joseph’s Prep in Philadelphia, Redding logged 25 minutes, had five rebounds, an assist and a pair of steals (although he also had a terrible night shooting – 2-11 from the floor, missing all of the half-dozen three-pointers he attempted, and finishing with just four points).

Benn was Villanova’s secret weapon. Benn played 19 minutes (more than twice his average of 9.4 minutes/game) scoring half a dozen points on 3-4 shooting, and finishing with four rebounds and three steals (albeit with three turnovers). All of these events culminated in Benn fouling out (the first time this season, that he had more than three fouls). The 19 minutes were the second-highest of the season (Benn's high is 20 minutes on November 30, 2006, at Stony Brook), and they were the most he had played since logging 16 minutes on December 6, 2006, @ Oklahoma.

City Series Superlatives

Holy War All-Time Series: Villanova has now increased its lead to 41-23, winning its third in a row.

Holy War in the Past Decade: Villanova has now won eight of the last ten meetings, in the seasons ending in ’97, ’99, 2000, ’01, ’02, ’05, ’06, and ’07, with SJU’s victories coming only in ’03 and ’04. (There was no game in 1998, due to Villanova’s absence from the full round-robin, during the 1990s.)

Holy War under Commanders Jay Wright/Phil Martelli: This is the first time that the two friends have faced each other as generals in the Holy War. Wright has now taken a 4-2 lead over Martelli, after the latter had gone up 2-1 after the 2004 game.

Holy War @ the Pavilion: Villanova now leads 5-2.

City Series Outright Championships: These back-to-back titles are Villanova’s 7th and 8th Big Five championships.

Villanova has now won eleven straight in City Series play – the last loss was against Temple, 53-52, at the Palestra, on December 2, 2004.

As noted above, Villanova secured its second straight outright City Series title. However, the 2006-07 season is among the most dominant 4-0 sweeps by any of the Big Five schools, in the half-century or so of the City Series’ existence. The reason: all four of Villanova’s victories were by double-digit margins:

December 2, 2006 – Palestra – W 99-89, over Penn (+ 10).
December 23, 2006 – Tom Gola Arena – W 64-51, over La Salle (+13).
December 30, 2006 – Pavilion – W 83-65, over Temple (+18).
February 6, 2007 – Pavilion – W 56-39, over St. Joseph’s (+17).

That’s a rarity in City Series play, to dominate all four opponents to such an extent.

Sights and Sounds


SJU made wise use of its 500 ticket allotment, which placed them in the apex of the ND section of the Pavilion. Given that they were outnumbered by a twelve-to-one margin by Wildcat partisans, they did succeed in making a lot of noise.

The Villanova pep band was outstanding, and here is a sampling of some of their set:

“V for Villanova” several times, of course;


“Let’s Get It Started” – The Black-Eyed Peas, to begin the game – that’s a great adrenaline-pumping song, for the opening;

“The Impression That I Get” – The Mighty Mighty Bosstones;

“You Can Call Me Al” – Paul Simon

“Mars”, from the classical composer Gustav Holst’s orchestral suite, “The Planets”. (Horst was an Englishman, despite his name. He completed the suite in 1916, with "Mars" as the opening movement - it is the most popular of Holst's compositions.)

The pep-band version of "Mars" is a song the Villanova bands plays often, and I was very familiar with it, as would be any frequenter of the Pavilion. However, I had never known its title, and so I asked the band after the game, for the answer. They told me – much to my surprise – that it was the classical piece described above: it's also known as “Mars” or “War”, since Mars was the ancient god of war. That’s the music that when played by the band, the student section will (in response) rhythmically pump their arms forward, as if they were signaling a first down in football. It has a very low, rumbling sound to it, and finishes in a big crescendo.

Missing in Action

Dwayne Anderson actually got into the game on Tuesday, something which he hadn’t done for a while. He played two minutes and had two rebounds, an assist and a turnover. While two minutes isn’t a lot, he hadn’t played a single minute in any of the Wildcats’ last four games. His most recent appearance, before the Holy War cameo, was against then-#21 Texas on January 20, 2007, where he saw 2 minutes. Although, of course, the sophomore clearly remains in Wright’s doghouse.

Will Sheridan’s numbers have also plunged sharply over the last two games: he played just 17 minutes in the February 3, 2007 victory over Louisville – and he played a season-low 13 minutes in the Holy War.

Next Up For the Wildcats

The Wildcats sail into the Pirates’ cove at the Meadowlands on Saturday, February 10, 2007. Seton Hall is having a rough year, and the cavernous Continental Airlines Arena is among the most visitor-friendly in the Big East. With the venue less-than-half-full, as it will be Saturday with Seton Hall struggling at 3-6 Big East, 12-10 overall, it’s a must-win for Villanova. The Pirates are the first of two weak opponents in the course of the next week, the other being Cincinnati on Valentine's Day.

Questions? Comments? Information? You can e-mail Craig Dimitri at
novaviewpoint@yahoo.com.



Villanova Holds SJU to Lowest Holy War Point Total in 68 Years, Cruising 56-39 at the Pavilion

by Craig Dimitri
E-mail:
novaviewpoint@yahoo.com

On Tuesday evening, February 6, 2007, at the Pavilion the Wildcats continued their distinctive dominance over the rest of the Big Five. Villanova won its second straight City Series crown, by cruising St. Joseph's, 56-39. The 39 points were the fewest the Hawks have scored against the Wildcats in 68 years! Not since - coincidentally - the 1939 season, has SJU's offense been so effectively stifled.

Or to put it another way - World War II had not yet started, the last time it happened.

The Wildcats also swept the Big Five in the 2005-06 season as well: going back to the 2004-05 season, Villanova has now won 11 consecutive City Series contests. Plus, VU has now defeated SJU three straight years. This is a streak which has delighted the Villanova faithful, and which we all hope will continue.


This post is a placeholder, a temporary recap, until a full, extended story - which such a glorious victory deserves - can be completed. Please stop back at Villanova Viewpoint, to read the entire story. Thank you.

Questions? Comments? Information? You can contact Craig Dimitri at novaviewpoint@yahoo.com.

Tuesday, February 06, 2007

A History of the Holy War: Villanova/St. Joseph's, As the Schools Clash for the 64th Time

by Craig Dimitri
E-mail: novaviewpoint@yahoo.com


Villanova leads the all-time series, 40-23. As members of the Big Five, the margin is considerably narrower: 29-22. Villanova had won eleven of the twelve meetings since the first game took place in 1921, until the formation of the Big Five in the 1955-56 season. 'Nova has done well in recent years, winning seven of the last nine contests. Most of the SJU victories came during the 1950s and 1960s; Villanova is 24-11 over the last three decades or so.

The telecast will be on ESPN2, at 7:00 PM; this is the sixth consecutive season that the ESPN networks have featured the Holy War as part of their "Rivalry Week" series in February.



The Origin of the Series, Prior to the Formation of the Big Five

Villanova played SJU (then St. Joseph's College) twice, during the Wildcats' first ever season on the hardwood, which took place during the 1920-21 school year. The first contest took place on January 15, 1921, on the Main Line, with 'Nova winning 31-22. In the return game, Villanova completed the sweep by prevailing 24-14. The teams clashed often during the 1920s, but after the 1930 game, the series lay dormant for a long time. In the ensuing quarter-century, the only meeting was in 1939. As to why two proximate Catholic schools would go so long without meeting - can't figure it out.

But when the Big Five got rolling, it was SJU's turn to dominate the series. The Hawks won the first six City Series games and ten of the first twelve. The two schools had the honor of clashing in the first-ever Big Five contest at the Palestra, on December 14, 1955- St. Joe's won, 83-70. Surprisingly, the public did not seem all that interested in the game, as a paltry 2,636 spectators showed up for the historic inaugural. Villanova was ordinary that year, finishing at 14-12, but St. Joe's went 25-6 and reached the NIT semifinals.

The lack of interest is even more surprising, in light of the fact that starting with the 1958 game, every single VU/SJU game attracted a sellout or near-sellout crowd at the Palestra, with the high attendance continuous for all games since then, regardless of venue. The attendance for the 1957 game climbed to 5,659, but then the Palestra was packed to the rafters for Villanova/St. Joe's.

Some Memorable Games in the Series (Villanova victories in light blue, St. Joseph's victories in crimson)

February 12, 1958

Villanova loses to St. Joe's, 86-82, in overtime, after failing to hold a 17 point lead.

January 28, 1961

St. Joe's was a powerhouse, and would finish with a 25-5 record under Jack Ramsay
, a deep NCAA tournament run, and a City Series sweep. In the last season for legendary coach Alexander Severance, Villanova would finish winless in City Series play and with a dismal 11-13 record. But the Wildcats nearly pulled off a huge upset, losing only 64-63.

March 3, 1962

New coach Jack Kraft leads the Wildcats to their first-ever City Series victory over the Hawks, prevailing 66-59. The victory gives Villanova its first City Series sweep, with Hubie White leading the way with 23 points and 17 rebounds. Both teams went on to the NCAA tournament, in an era when the tournament field was very small.
February 20, 1965

This was the most titanic clash in Holy War history, as in no other year have both schools simultaneously posted such gaudy records. St. Joe's would finish at 26-3, with a 4-0 City Series sweep, and reach the NCAA tournament. Villanova would finish at 23-5 and reach the NIT semifinals. And when they met head-to-head, there was a bizarre incident - a bomb scare at the Palestra. According to a perhaps legendary tale, radio broadcaster Les Keiter
refused to go off the air during the threat, announcing his intention to stay there all night if necessary. It turned out to be a false alarm, and the Hawks won, 69-62.

January 16, 1966

In one of the most written about Big Five finishes, Hawk substitute Steve Donches
connects on a 29-footer at the buzzer to give SJU a 71-69 victory.

January 11, 1969

The legendary Wildcat center Howard Porter turns in one of his most incredible performances, scoring 36 points and grabbing 26 rebounds to help Villanova blow out St. Joe's, 87-62. The 25 point margin was Villanova's most lopsided victory in the series to that point. The performance helps propel Porter to a share of the Geasey Award (the Big Five MVP) with La Salle's Ken Durrett.

February 20, 1971/March 13, 1971

In Villanova's second-greatest season, the Porter-led Wildcats will go 23-6 and reach the NCAA championship game before bowing to John Wooden's UCLA dynasty. But en route, they meet St. Joe's twice in one season, for the first time since 1923. In the City Series game, Villanova triumphs 63-55, although Hawks center Mike Bantom
outplays Porter.

The schools would meet again at the Palestra, in the first round of the NCAA tournament (the only time, before or since, the Holy War has extended to postseason play). 'Nova won in a rout, 93-75.

January 27, 1973

In Kraft's final season, Villanova scuffled to a rare losing record at 11-14. St. Joe's went 22-6 and to the NCAA tournament. But the Wildcats shocked the heavily favored Hawks, 79-72, with 43 points coming from Tom Ingelsby- the Geasey winner - and Ed Hastings.

February 22, 1975

Rollie Massimino wins his first game against the Hawks: Larry and Keith Herron each score 19 points in Villanova's 71-67 victory. The attraction of the rivalry was quite evident at this point. Villanova and St. Joe's finished with disastrous 9-18 and 8-17 records, respectively. La Salle and Penn had fantastic seasons, in contrast. But Villanova/St. Joe's drew 9,233 fans, the 3rd-highest total of the ten City Series contests. (Penn/Villanova and Penn/La Salle were the only others to draw more than 7,300).

February 19, 1977

The first City Series game away from the Palestra, as the Villanova/St. Joe's game goes to the Spectrum, to accommodate more fans for both schools. The Wildcats win 92-78, in front of 12,138 fans.

February 23, 1980

For the first time, the Wildcats and Hawks meet while both squads are 3-0 in City Series play. In front of a sold-out Palestra, the Hawks came away with a narrow 60-59 victory to give St. Joe's its first City Series title since 1968.

February 22, 1983

In the second Spectrum game in the series, a record throng of 18,060 witnesses a 70-62 Wildcat victory, the most to ever witness a Holy War.

February 19, 1985

It was the annus mirabilis (in Latin, the "year of miracles") on the Main Line. And perhaps the basketball gods' first sign of favor took place at the Spectrum, in the Holy War.

Villanova entered the game having lost three in a row, while the Hawks had won nine straight. Villanova was 3-0 in City Series play, but SJU was 1-1 and could pursue a share of the Big Five title with a victory over the 'Cats. 'Nova started the game on a 9-2 run, but by halftime the Hawks had overtaken them, 22-19. St. Joe's led 30-23 with 14:18 to go, before 'Nova rallied. Ed Pinckney connected on two free throws to draw the Wildcats even at 44 with 3:08 to play.


It seems odd to write this today, in the era of the shot clock, but SJU nearly succeeded in holding the ball for three minutes to take the last shot. Dwayne McClain rebounded the errant St. Joe's shot with only four seconds to go. On the inbounds play, McClain hit a 18-footer and was fouled. By converting the three-point play, McClain gave Villanova a 47-44 victory- and the outright Big Five title for the first time since 1967.

McClain's 18 points and Harold Pressley's 14 points paced 'Nova, as they each went 7-11 from the floor.
Rodney Blake
led the Hawks with 14 points and 10 rebounds.

February 19, 1987

"Daddy Mass" had the chance to win his 300th game against the Hawks. It took double overtime at the Palestra, but the Wildcats finally delivered an 88-87 victory. (Once a perennial fixture at the Palestra, it would be the last Holy War at the basketball cathedral for over seven years, until December 1994).

December 12, 1988

The Hawks soar into the Pavilion for the first time ever, facing a powerful Wildcat squad that would reach the Elite Eight come March. But the heavy-underdog Hawks pull off a 53-52 upset over Doug West, Mark Plansky and Tom Greis, thanks to a 15-foot bank shot by the obscure "Pick" Brown.
(Villanova finished the season at 24-13, the Hawks at 15-14.)

December 18, 1994

The Holy War, now taking place every other year due to Villanova's 1991-99 withdrawal from the full round-robin, returns to the Palestra for the first time in over six years. #22 Villanova - at the apex of the Kerry Kittles era - is a heavy favorite over a small, slow St. Joe's squad. (The Hawks hadn't reached postseason play since 1986.) But Dmitri Domani hits two key free throws down the stretch, to give St. Joe's a 60-57 upset victory. Kittles graduates as the first Wildcat superstar since the 1950s, to never beat St. Joe's (albeit with only two opportunities, rather than four). Although nobody knew it at the time, it would be the last Holy War for SJU coach John Griffin, who also had been a Hawk player; he resigned at the end of the season, and was replaced by one of his longtime assistants, Phil Martelli. However
, St. Joe's would not defeat Villanova again, for another decade.

December 23, 1996

At Christmas time, Villanova coach Steve Lappas, as well as stars Alvin Williams and Jason Lawson, finally defeat St. Joe's. The #10 Wildcats had only one disadvantage - the absence of freshman sensation Tim Thomas, sidelined with an injury. After struggling in the first half, the Wildcats go on a 24-3 run in the second half to win easily, 81-65. (There is a huge Pavilion crowd of 6,672, including a healthy number of Hawk partisans able to obtain tickets, with the VU students on break.)

The victory looks more significant in light of subsequent events than it seemed at the time. St. Joe's - which hadn't been to the NCAA tournament in over a decade - went on to a highly unexpected 26-7 season and Sweet 16 appearance. However, at the time the 'Nova victory was considered routine, given the Wildcats' vast advantages in talent (even with Thomas out).

December 1, 1998 -
Palestra

The Wildcats make it two in a row over the Hawks, 61-49, thanks to 15 points each from seniors Howard Brown and Rafal Bigus. Brown punctuates the game with several acrobatic feats, including a highly memorable tip dunk.

February 17, 2000 - Pavilion

This was the first Holy War to take place, after the joyous announcement during the previous off-season, that Villanova would resume participation in the full-round robin, starting with the 1999-2000 season. The Wildcats had been absent from the round-robin, beginning with the 1991-92 season, an eight-year absence.


Marvin O'Connor,
who transferred from 'Nova to St. Joe's after his freshman season of 1997-98, takes on his former teammates for the first time. (Intra-Big Five transfers are rare.) O'Connor leads the Hawks with 20 points, but on only 8-24 shooting. Gary Buchanan singlehandedly gives the Wildcats a hard-fought, 68-61 victory, with a 24 point outburst.

December 11, 2000

The Holy War returns to the Palestra. St. Joe's comes close to its long-denied victory over the Wildcats, leading 39-32 at intermission. O'Connor dazzles with 32 points on 11-17 shooting to lead the Hawks. But 'Nova rallies in the second half to come away with a hard-fought, thrilling 78-75 victory. Michael Bradley has a field day in the paint, scoring 20 points and grabbing 10 rebounds. Reggie Bryant and Aaron Matthews add 13 for the 'Cats.

February 2002 - Pavilion

In the first Holy War under Jay Wright, Villanova eviscerated SJU at the Pavilion, 102-73, the largest margin of victory for either side in the then-81 year history of the series. Gary Buchanan led the way with 28 points, including a career-high seven three-pointers.

February 2003 - Palestra

Martelli had been the most successful coach at SJU since Jack Ramsay
, having won Atlantic 10 titles and reached a Sweet 16 in 1997. He defeated Villanova for the first time in six tries, as the Hawks humiliated the 'Cats, 92-75, at the Palestra. Incredibly, the 17-point final margin does not accurately reflect, how lopsided the game actually was.

During the first eight minutes, the Wildcats committed 15 turnovers and scored three baskets. The Hawks started the contest on a 40-9 run - and the 17-point deficit was actually the closest Villanova drew after that, during the entire game. (One particularly zealous Hawk partisan actually had the opening run immortalized on his Pennsylvania license plate: "SJ40-VU9".)

Jameer Nelson had 30 points to lead the Hawks. Delonte West,
who had been the lead story entering the game, after media reports surfaced regarding an altercation he had allegedly had with the SJU trainer, did not start as a result. But playing 26 minutes, he scored 25 points.

February 2004

The #3 Hawks entered the Pavilion soaring as high as they ever have, bringing an unblemished 18-0 mark into the game; they would eventually garner a #1 seed in the NCAA tournament and reach the Elite Eight. However, the Wildcats substantially improved upon the sorry spectacle of the previous year. The overmatched Wildcats fought admirably before finally falling, 74-67.

Nelson and West combined for 45 points, but Mike Nardi led the Wildcat counterattack with 16 points and five assists. A three-pointer from Andreas Bloch cut the Hawk lead to 54-50, with less than nine minutes to play, before what had to have been one of the largest crowds in Pavilion history. But that was as close as 'Nova came to an upset.

February 2005

By a remarkable twist of fate, Super Bowl XXXIX between the Philadelphia Eagles and the New England Patriots is scheduled for the previous day. And so Holy War LXII is relegated to the back burner. Lost amidst the avalanche of Super Bowl coverage, it was the probably the least hyped battle between the two schools since the formation of the Big Five.

VU was enjoying its first great year, under Jay Wright, and entered the contest with a #22 ranking. SJU was coming off a remarkable season in which they were undefeated until the Atlantic 10 tournament and ranked #1 for a week. The Hawks had reached the Elite Eight (moreover, coming within a Jameer Nelson shot of reaching the Final Four), and with both teams enjoying a renaissance, it should have had the makings of a fantastic contest. However, the melancholia of the crowd (for both teams) was too much to overcome. The Patriots' vanquishing of the Eagles the previous evening cast a funereal pall over the proceedings, like a vast, billowing fog through which no other sporting event could shine.

And as it turned out, the game wasn't all that good, anyway. The Wildcats were never challenged in a slow, foul-marred game, which they won, 67-52. Jason Fraser had arguably the finest game of his star-crossed career, coming off the bench to score 14 points, grab 14 rebounds and block two shots, despite being hampered by a heavily bandaged hand and playing only 29 minutes. The Hawks'
Pat Carroll, a superb outside shooter, would miss his first 13 shots, as SJU had mustered only 20 points with less than 14 minutes to play.

Finally, the Hawks' band would play, during garbage time, a mournful version of "Fly, Eagles, Fly", accurately reflecting what was on the mind of the Palestra crowd...

February 7, 2006 - Palestra

It was the 50th Anniversary of the creation of the Big Five. And as fate would have it, both teams entered the sold-out, packed-beyond-capacity Palestra, with perfect 3-0 City Series marks: the winner would take the 50th Big Five title. This represented only the fourth time in the Big Five's half-century history, that two schools would enter a City Series contest, with both having 3-0 records.

And despite a terrible first half, Villanova ended up withe the chance to savor another City Series sweep. Despite the unavailability of a tonsillitis-stricken Mike Nardi, the #4 Wildcats were heavy favorites over the Hawks. And so there was much astonishment in the venerable building, when St. Joseph's dominated the first half. Villanova was trailing by double-digits, 34-22, at halftime. But Villanova rallied to defeat the Hawks, 71-58, for the second year in a row, capturing the City Series crown. "Nova annihilated SJU after intermission, winning the second half by more than doubling up the Hawks, 49-24. The Wildcats shot a stunning 68% in the second half, after scuffling to an anemic 30% in the first half.

Kyle Lowry, playing in his second (and since he ultimately left early for the NBA, final) contest with SJU, scored 25 points, including 17 in the second-half counterattack, which featured a 21-3 Wildcats run. The gifted senior backcourt of Allan Ray and Randy Foye also contributed 14 points apiece. For SJU, Chet Stachitas had 19 points, with Abdulai Jalloh adding 15 points and Dwayne Lee recording 11 points.


Another chapter, to be written Tuesday night...